November 1st, 2009
08:26 AM ET

Dear President Obama #286: The swine flu doubters

Reporter's Note: The Administration has been dealing with tough questions about the short supply of swine flu vaccine. But they’ve been dealing with something else too: A serious case of doubt among many Americans. I have no doubt my daily letter to the president could help.

[cnn-photo-caption image=http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/2009/HEALTH/10/13/h1n1.flu.young.adults/art.h1n1.vaccine.csl.gi.jpg]

Tom Foreman | BIO
AC360° Correspondent

Dear Mr. President,

You might guess from my name, Thomas, that I am a doubting sort by nature and you would be right. I doubt that I’ll get much taller. I doubt that I will ever be called by a professional sports team to fill in when they run out of quarterbacks. I doubt that I will ever become a big fan of Dancing With the Stars. Not that I haven’t tried.

And I doubt science sometimes; when it makes shaky claims, when research is being paid for groups with too much vested interest in a slanted outcome, and when a scientist’s ideas run too fiercely counter to the body of knowledge built over many years by many others. (That last one is a little tricky for me, because I often believe that when “everyone knows” something it is probably not true, and I’ve always been a great admirer of pioneers who come up with something utterly new. Like Tupperware for instance.)

All of that being said, however, I’m having a little trouble understanding all the folks who doubt the science of the H1N1 vaccine. Their chief concerns seem to be that the vaccine was developed quickly, that the virus we are dealing with is a bit novel and unknown, and they just don’t feel comfortable having anything related to all that injected into their bodies. Fair enough. It’s a free country. Or at least mostly. The problem is, when we are dealing with a pandemic I think we have to ask ourselves what matters more: and individual’s rights or society’s well-being?