Reporter's Note: I am writing a letter each day to the White House. I have done so every day since President Barack Obama took office. Sometimes it gets rather tiring, but I suppose I can keep enduring it as long as he can.
Tom Foreman | Bio
Dear Mr. President,
Ever since you announced your first Supreme Court nominee, I have been gnashing my teeth amid an onslaught of what surely must be one of the worst plagues to hit American politics since the last time British Regulars marched on the colonies. Of course I am talking about the latest Talking Points war.
On the left and the right, this relentless parade of people defending and attacking your nominee is far too often characterized not be actual discussion or ideas, but instead by mindless recitation of Talking Points; prepared arguments for or against confirmation that are droned out like the prayers of monks, and with seemingly no less faith in the divine power of the words. At least some of the monks have the decency to make their petitions in private.
We (meaning the media) are complicit of course; we put these babbling Charlie McCartheys on the air as if they have something to say, and then pepper them with questions as if we expect them to really answer. It all produces a kind of political Kubuki theater, no matter which party is playing.
Interviewer: What about Jackson versus The Five; don’t you think Sonia Sotomayor’s ruling deserves scrutiny in that case?
Dem Party Hack: She has more judicial experience than Solomon himself!
Dem Party Hack: You’re right about that: She is remarkably intelligent.
Interviewer: Uh, let’s ask your counterpart in the other party. Thoughts?
Repub Party Hack: She’s not to be trusted. Have you read what she told her student paper in 6th grade?
Repub Party Hack: Exactly. And we don’t need a judicial activist on the bench.
That’s sort of how it goes. I think the groundwork for this relentless refusal to actually discuss issues, was oddly enough pioneered by the old Alabama Governor George Wallace. When he was near the end of his final term, and quite hard of hearing, he could become stone deaf the moment he was asked a question that might be politically delicate to answer. No kidding, I actually witnessed exchanges that went sort of like this.
Interviewer: Governor, will you give the teachers a raise?
Governor: Fishing? Sure I like fishing.
Talking points are designed purely to reduce political risk. They are a way for both parties to avoid any genuine discussion of matters that might actually illuminate the public about any issue; and in place of that discussion is an insult…the notion that if you shove a message at Americans long enough and hard enough, and ignore any questions or facts that get in the way, that voters are just too stupid to notice.
Talking points are not about honest talk at all. They are certainly not about listening. And that’s really a shame, if you get my point.
All that said, hope your Monday is off to a good start. Back in town and back in the office, so ring me up if you get a moment. Want to grab a salad? I’d say a burger, but I need to behave a bit after playing cholesterol roulette in Louisiana. Ha!
Find more of the Foreman Letters, here.
Anderson Cooper goes beyond the headlines to tell stories from many points of view, so you can make up your own mind about the news. Tune in weeknights at 8 and 10 ET on CNN.
Questions or comments? Send an email
Want to know more? Go behind the scenes with