Carl,
I don't want to hear anything about his family. I could care less. We have heard it all before. Obama needs to tell where he stands on the issues and give a plan..a detailed plan on how he is going to change them. Not just I want to make this change but I want to make this change and this is how I am going to do it. If we don't get that then in my mind he will have failed.

Cindy...Ga.

Carl, I don't know what convention you're watching but to suggest that Obama "is getting the convention he wants" is beyond the pale.

If this convention "reflects him and his priorities" then I would say Obama, the Democrats and our nation needs to get their priorities straight.

Obama, preaching unity and change, failed to unify his OWN party prior to the convention; that's egregious and unacceptable.

Day 1: all about Ted kennedy; Day 2: Hillary hits a homerun; Day 3: Bill Clinton's time; best orator since Reagan; Hillary even helped steal the show by handing over the nomination to Obama.

Obama is left to try and make an impression on day four; it's as if Obama is another swimmer in the same Olympics as Michael Phelps.

Obama should have been at the convention all four days showing leadership of his party and convincing America; lost opportunity.

Great article Carl, I think this entire campaign is proof that Obama is indeed ready to lead. McCain is bogged down with the special interest groups & the Republican party who are trying to play the same old negative political game. Obama runs a tight ship, he doesn't fall apart over the poll numbers or the McCain ads, he just keeps moving ahead. Great qualities to have in a leader. I have been very impressed with this convention, anyone who pays attention will see the changes. A Republican actually put Obama's name into nomination, he has such a gift for uniting people. I think Americans are lucky to have him.

I have heard political and news pundits over and over again talk about how very boring this convention is. However , I think that if you all would just quiet down and reframe from all your own subjective commentaries, we ( the viewing audience) might be able to hear more, learn more and decide for ourselves, if its worth our time to listen. Be Fair – we don't need your help to vote.

Tommye – New Orleans.

I believe Obama will win big in November 4th!

Democrat party is doing a great job so far. I can't see that McCain has any chance this time. It is the time for Republican leaves the White house.

Obama should have put HIllary as he VP. Whatever Mark Penn said in his e-mails and notes about making Obama look "unamerican"- Clinton in NO way went down that road. The real truth appears to be that he was never going to put her on as VP- and the " convenient line" that she would be on anyone's short list is just that- a convenient line of ___! Hillary has done more than any other losing candidate in history. She has done more than she should have to do!

The real story here is that Obama has to win this election on his own- he has to explain his comments about people such as myself in PA that are bitter and cling to religion and guns . He has to convince us- Clinton and Biden will not be able to. He's the nominee- he has to get out there and carry a SPECIFIC message about his what his agend a will be if elected President.

It's a sad day for many of us that Obama didn't look past himself and his ego to what could have and should have been- both on the ticket and a practical guarantee of victory.

Carl – I really hope you will write a follow up book about Hillary and the Clinton camp during this primary race. I was a college student who cried when they accepted the nomination envisioning the great future we all had as Americans during their stewardship of the country. Probably like many, I'm now caught in the yin and yang of the administration's accomplishments and its members' disgraces, particularly of President and Mrs. Clinton. In particular, I was disgusted by what I learned about their treatment of the Gores in his presidential run held at the same time as Hillary ran for senate. Please if you have not already started volume two, keep your notes from this week and share them with the country.

Experience vs Change

The old adage "Experience is the best Teacher" is true in many cases. Take for instance the current Republican Administration. Their years of experience has led us to:

Higher Gas Prices
Largest Financial Deficit
Casualties of War
No Confidence in our Government

John McCain not only used his experience and judgement to support the current administration…his decisions helped reinforce and solidify a failing government structure.

What has this experience taught us? It's time for Change!

Obama/Biden 2008

Just wanted to say how impressive Hillary Clinton has been the last two nights. I was beginning to believe she would end up as the 'Ralph Nader' of the 2008 election by splitting the party and handing the election to the Republicans. Instead, in two days, she has shown herself to be one of the best spoken communicator and motivators of our time. I am sure she will be a great asset to the Obama administration in what ever capacity she ends up filling.

Regarding experience – would you rather have a president who graduated at the top of his class in constitutional law or a president who graduated at the bottom of his class at a naval academy?

To many a democrat Obama has done it all very well. I know he is very capable, very well organized in every state and fueled by those who really care for our country. The Obama message of change and hope has laid in waiting since RFK. We, us democrats have been waiting for that change. I would hope that all of us as Americans are inspired by that promise. I would also hope for those opposed to racial barriers, both democrat and republican, wake up and accept that change. In leadership we are defined as a country..in prejudice we are weakened as a country.

Congratulations to Barack Obama, The Clintons, the Democratic Party and the American People. Finally we have a man for the people! I am tired of the commentary instead of being allowed to listen to the speakers! For God's sake, give it a break. I will definitely be watching the Repub. Convention to see if they get the same treatment!

It is on to November and see if majority of people will rise over the xenophobia of the obama name.

To be able to witness "live"...the historic event when Hillary Clinton joined her fellow New Yorkers on the floor of the convention and asked the delegates to forego the 'vote counts' roll call to give Barack Obama the nomination by acclaimation!...and a rousing "YES" burst forth and MADE HISTORY!! I would ask that people stop with the Clinton "bashing"...this couple made history of their own, and have ALWAYS been 'servants of the people'...OUR people, ALL colors, ALL creeds...ALL AMERICANS!! President Clinton has joined with his wife, and will support OUR candidate: Barack Obama...all the way to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. They will always be voices for US...and I DO mean U. S.! God speed and God Bless OUR America!!

Barack Obama has shown great character throughout this campaign season. He is like the boat sailing through the Atlantic sea, fighting through a Perfect Storm continuing to keep upfloat no matter how increasingly strong the storms becomes. While the constant criticism remains strong from the Mccain campaign as well as the media, he has always stayed presidential, cool, and collected. Proof of this happened just recently,when times became increasingly difficult, he did not follow what many in the media thought was the right choice, including CNN, which was to pick Hillary as his VP, but he chose the person who he feels he can work best with. This is only one of the many reasons why I am a passionate Barack Obama supporter. He truly believes in his heart that change can occur in our country. And throughout this convention, his prescence has been felt, and his vison to bring America together is what will inspire all of us to do what is truly best for our country. To look in our hearts and elect Barack Obama as our President of the United States.

He may have out-organized the Clintons, but Obama beat the "toughest Democratic machine of modern times" because the media never asked him a serious question and lined-up with the rest of the kool-aid drinkers. If you don't think that's true, ask Chris Matthews how that tingle he gets up his leg every time Obama speaks is compared to the shrill he hears when Hillary speaks!

I am a Clinton supporter–an Independent-who will vote for Senator McCain, nol because I'm bitter, but because I consider McCain to be the better man for the job. Obama is arrogant, and arrogant people in power are dangerous.

finally, intelligent analysis without the sensationalism or agenda. yer one of the greats carl, please write a journalism 101 instruction book and create a foundation to get one in the hands of all the hacks out there ONLY in it for the money, please? i used to think journalists would save our country (yeah i was a young teen during watergate) lately it seems they have become a large part of the problem, kudos my brother

So far, and if things continue to work as well as they have, I believe Hillary Clinton will have earned herself a place in history by graciously stepping aside and helping to unite the Democratic Party. I do recall, however, at least a couple times during the debates when she said she would support the nominee in the event that she didn't win. I believed her then and was not surprised over the powerful speech she delivered last night. She did what was right and we expected no less from her. Still, this must have been very difficult for her. After all that traveling and exhausting campaigning, this disappointment must have been hard to accept. She is a very strong person and I have to admire her for her strength and accomplishments.

I am from Hawaii & a Kucinich backer. then, I switched to Hillary. I had the privilege to listen to her on the 2nd day of the Democratic convention. She was awesome.. However, we must move on, therefore, I will vote for Obama. After he is president, think of her as a Supreme Court justice. Stevens is 88 yrs young & will surely retire. Scalia & Thomas wil retire after facing her & we will have a liberal court. And, she will in for life; no need to run for election. Thank you Jesus, Mary & Joseph! Then, our dreams will become realities. ALOHA & MAHALO!

After listening to both Bill and Hillary (she is a class act!), I know why I supported her in the primaries. I know where they stand and I know what they stand for. I can say I still do not know where Obama stands. I have never heard from him half the issues of what I heard from the Clintons thus far. But the few things I do know I do not like such as his far left friends, Rev. Wright, and his flip-flopping on just about everything just to get what he wants. I'm sorry but Michelle's speech on Monday was not a true picture of her. As the camera kept shooting to her during Hillary's speech – that is the true Michelle when she doesn't think anyone is looking....or listening. I continue to support McCain now that Hillary is out of the picture. Too bad.

I just listened to Bill Clinton endorse Barack Obama. He was as usual dynamic! Just as Hillary was last night, and Michelle was the night before. They are making the point that I have seen from the beginning. Barack Obama is the man for the job! In the final analysis, the Clintons are not just Democrats. They are Good People and good Americans.... they are good servants of the People ! They have both worked for the common good of all Americans from the first that they came to national attention. Barack Obama has that same drive for the well being of all the people, not just the most wealthy of our population. I love the Clintons. And now I am ready to love the Obamas. Can't People just FEEL the same drive in those four people? I can. I knew Clinton was the man to make the difference. I know that Obama is the man for the job this time! God Bless us all, God bless the Clintons, God bless Barack Obama, the next president of the United States of America, and his family!

The Clintons, as a couple, have poured the foundation on which this momentous event...the selection of an Afro-American for the Democratic nominee...is being realized. To carp at petty behavior is to avoid the real acknowledgment that these two dedicated individuals have accomplished under extraordinary social and political pressures. Lets not seek perfection, rather human dedication under stress, commitment to one's mate and to the fulfillment of America's dream. This event is truly an American response to the world, after 8 years of perfidy, to the basic principals that founded this country and gives hope to the oppressed, the enslaved and the disenfranchised that we Americans are not perfect, but we learn from our mistakes and never, never give up hope and drive to set an example for the world. Listen, World, here is our answer to Russia and Georgia, to Dafur, to New Orleans, to 9/11...here is how we respond in times of need: we are the light to every wandering bark...watch and be inspired.

It isdiffficult to understand how any hard working American who supports there family could support any democrate. I have not heard any that support self reliance, courage and limited government. I think they are all for more government (federal) and less power for the people.

Carl Berstein needs to stop trying to spin every victorious moment that Hillary Clinton has as anything other than glorious. Many admire her, many love her and many more RESPECT HER for what she is: a smart, sassy, intelligent and extermely effective human being in ushering policies for the greater public good. Hillary has and will continue to have: 18 million loyal and fervent supporters. (I am sure Carl Berstein can't say that about himself , that he has 18 million people that think that highly of him).

Millions were wowed by Hillary Clinton speechs that was electriying last night . And all Hilary Clintons' s personal speech did was to demonstrate how she is the bigger person by letting the party know that it is about the cause that the democratic party seeks to be in government to do greater good. Obama could not even try to rach across hos own party lines to bring Hillary Clinton on as a VP – which would habe undoubtedly won the democrats the election hands down. And for that error in judgement alone, Obama's star is fading quickly to reveal a man very much egotistical about how he need to always be the star of his own show. Obama wants to be president not for the democrats but for himself and his own glory. Hillary Clinton had wanted the prsidency to do good. Which the democrats may loose the chance to capture now. If the democrats lose this 2008 election, the blame for that loss lies solely on Barack Obama's shoulders. Barack Obama made the wrong decision not to select Hilary Clinton as his VP. Only time will tell if America will have the fortunate luck to be able to elect Hillary Clinton as President 4 years from now and to get it right next time!!!

All I can say is I can't wait for the end of the unelected czar George Bush's reign.
The Republicans have had their run, the economy is in a slump, the rich have gotten richer, jobs have been oursourced, plants closed and real Americans out of jobs. With gasoline and food prices sky rocketing, how are these out of work Americans going to buy all those imported goods from China. Bush has borrowed so much from Communist China, that he had to attend the Olympics, whether he liked it or not, as he was afraid they would refuse to loan him more. Go Obama, from a staunch supporter of Hillary Clinton.

Bill and Hillary Clinton have saved Obama. He needs to be grateful to them. If it were not for the words of Bill and Hillary Clinton I would still be for Mcain. So Obama supporters stop your negative attacks on the Clintons!

Well said!!!!

Mr. Obama will set the tune on Thursday night before 75 to 80
thousand Americans. His speach will be on Americas' future
and Her standings around the world. He is going to lay out his
plans for moving America forward into the 21st century. I think he
will also tell American people what he is going to do for all
Amreican. Mr. Obama is representing the democratic party, but
Mr. Obama vision is to represent all Americans regardless
of race, color or creed. This is going to be a different America, not
the America of the last 8 years. God sends some special in
a life time,and Mr. Obama has been chosen to lead America.

Hillary and Bill both did a great job showing how qualified they both are but nothing to convince me of Obama's credentials. In fact, i don't beleive a word of it. Political expediancy. They have no choice. I beleive the better Hillary does the worse for Obama. She proves she could have won and produced. Obama is weak because he needs both the Clintons and Joe Biden to get elected. He is the least experienced and least qualified candidate to run.

Dude,
Old dude is toast. I mean face it, after her brief forray into politics we saw even Paris Hilton has what it takes to handle old dude. Obama is going to roll over him like a nightmare. The pathetic attempts to flail at the hits these successive fantasic speeches we've enjoyed, is to show heavily edit footage making Obama seem like a mystery. That's it! Nothing about what he can do just all about how Obama seems like a mystery which nobody is really bying anymore. Maybe old dude should take on Romney as a VP, he needs someone with the experience of cutting his losses and running.

I have no doubt Obama will carefully lay-out the specifics of his agenda tomorrow night...the agenda that's been available for ten months on his website in full detail...way to go lazy America, God forbid you take a half hour to read it!

Carl,

Thank you for being honest.
And you are right.
Don't worry, Sen. Obama will do that and more.
He will pop up all across the USA and prove that he is more than prepared to lead our beloved country.

Craig
in OK.

Carl,
I don't agree with most of what you say, I get paricularly offended when people like you feel the need to interpret that which we see, read and hear for ourselves.
Bill Clinton has the "chutapah" after 18 months of saying that Obama is NOT Qualified to suddenly say he is Qualified. How demeaning, how shameful that is. The same for Hillary.This is insulting to anyone who doesn't worship idols and a very good reason to vote AGAINST Obama.
Senator Obama in fact has No Experience, No resume, a constituency that raises numerous red flags. He has changed everything he said announced and he is the most liberal member of congress. Joe Biden completed the circle of hypocracy as he is the third most liberal member of congress with 35 yrs, in the senate as opposed to 22 for McCain. If, as Obama has said McCain has done nothing on 22yrs. how does Biden's 35 yrs. in the very same Senate stack up? Then there is the age discrimination. McCain is 72 Biden is 65. That's not exactly a generation gap.
Obama is a man who wants to redistribute income(socialism), raise taxes, increase spending and act as commander in chief of our armed forces. He has NO credentials and his entire campaign has been theatrics and slight of hand with NO facts to support his rhetoric.
How come you don't draw the differences Carl? You are obviously a Democratic shill and myself and many others know it.

As a 55 year old white female, I am proud of Obama. I also think that Michelle and Hillary did an amazing job at the convention. I have never supported Hillary but I think she was amazing last night and I think it brought out the best in her. If I would have seen that same spirit during the primaries, I might have supported her but instead I saw her "kitchen sink" approach and her breaking any rule that didn't help her. The MI and FL issue really turned me against her. After last night, I believe in her ablitity to bring the democrats together for their unified goals. Thank you Hillary.

Lynne: I don't really care who graduated where in their class. What I care about is people's judgments. Obama sat in a church, with his wife and his children for over 20years. How could you let your children hear the remarks Rev. Wright made. How can you trust a man who Is friends with a man and his wife who bombed U.S. Government Buildings, or killed police in bombings. Study books in school is real easy for some people and good grades come easy for alot of people. It's what they do with their lives after school, that concerns me.

I was pleased that President Clinton acknowledge that John McCain is a good man, who has served, sacrificed and suffered for the country and shown independence from the Bush administration. Ironically the worst racist attak in recent memory was perpetrated against the McCains and their adopted black daughter by Bush. That's why no matter what the dems say the country knows McCain-agree with him or not-is no Bush clone. I also thought that both Bill & Hillary outshined Michele & Barack-and I think it was their intention.

I believe that Obama has defined himself enough. We all know where he stands. However, I found a double standard with regard to Obama. When Bill Clinton was a candidate for president, not many people knew about him even though he has been governor of Arkansas. The Republicans joked about his experience. Bush father stated that his dog had more experience than Bill Clinton back then. But it was fine with all the democrats. He did not need to define himself or to tell us where he stands.

Why is it that Obama has to go through more than the other candidates. I believe it's racial. Bill Clinton did not have to go through all that with his little experience. The reason is because he is white. White democrats identified themselves with him. They look alike so they think they share the same values. They did not really care about where Clinton stood.

Obama is different. He does not look like them. He's half white half black. So They think he does not share their values. He's educated, they think he is Elitist. He has a different name so they think he might be foreign.

Who's fault is that? Obama's? The democratic party's for failing to defend another democrat? or the democrats' for being racist?

Think about that.

it does not matter who wins or loses, some will always find fault either with the party, Hillary or Obama but I must admit that the Obama camp has put together a well oiled machine. If he wins and can organize and get the government to run more like he has run his campaign I suspect we will see some gains in this country. I am aware that there are those that will not vote for him but if he wins, he WILL be the president of ALL THE PEOPLE.

The Democratic Party is by all definition, UNITED. This week, that was made indubitably clear with incredible speeches by Michelle Obama, Senator Hillary Clinton, and former President Bill Clinton. Senator Clinton's roll call was breath-taking and brought me to tears. I look forward to Senator Obama's acceptance speech on Thursday, and I will continue to work diligently to elect Senator Obama as President of the United States of America.

Get a pill for your anti-Clinton attitude.
You and Cafferty need to readjust to women in power and not in the context of males they are with.

Great speeches by two great folks- Hill and Bill but I am still switching to McCain.

This race is so over. Up next is the Hot Head convention....where morons from all states who want to be raped will line up for a third flogging. Once we get this Conservatards/Repulitards convention over us can all get down to the business of turning the corner and getting this country back on track.

We were heading in the right direction as a country then came the thief in the night the 2000 election and ever since that coup they have sapped this country dry. It's funny, all the republitards know how to do and do well is run on a campaign of FEAR!!!! FEAR THIS..OR FEAR THAT...do you people not ever get tired of living in fear? If that’s the only way to live then why live at all? How long can we go around forcing a PAX AMERICANA on the world? (See JFK)...
So next week we will hear....Obama has no experience, he has a terrible voting record (actually better than McCain’s), he

Look people JFK said it best "There is no Book on how to be President!, There is no job to prepare you for that!" Bill Clinton led us to prosperity, JFK pointed us in a new direction...Obama has the promise to do the same. Four more years of the same? Are you that stupid? Yes he was in a POW camp....but being shot down and a POW does not make you ready to be President. In fact he has flip flopped on almost every major issue. Is it not a coincidence that now the current administration is doing everything Obama outlined with regards to the War/Iran/Georgia etc? Even the Republitards are following Obama!

And McCain is not arrogant? Come on......

Not only is he arrogant, he is hotheaded and impetuous. Is that who you want answering that 3 A.M. call?

McCain supporters, please stop being mean. No one is belittling you or spewing venum to you. If you support McCain, that's fine–vote for him and leave it at that. If you're happy with your candidate, you should be in a GREAT mood; not a mean-spirited one.

Senator Obama has been a good and decent man. In contrast, the remarks from the bloggers above have not been good or descent.

I'm sorry, but growing up going to private school in Hawaii is not a typical American by any stretch. I would've given my eye teeth to do that!

And if making Hillary eat crow is his defining accomplishment, then we are in more trouble than I feared.

Where is the positive campaign Obama promised? Where is the change? What is he doing to address sexism in our society? etc. etc.

He has a long ways to go – do we have the time?

Obama; not a lot of experience.
McCain; cannot work 7 days a week.

I believe that Mr. Obama or Mr. Mcain do not have a Clue when It comes to the real state of the Economy. This will sink either as President. We are the greatest Debtor nation In the history of Economic tracking, Have lost our Manufacturing base and all these Fools talk about is who is doing who and raising Taxes. Well, most of us don't care on the former and realize that the Chinese will not pay the latter....... A pox on all their houses !!!!

carl: your article reflects a correct picture of the convention. your suggestions commands insight.
there is no denying the fact that it's a convention unparallel in history. foresight of obama and statesmanship of clintons (shaking off personal ego) really made the convention a lifetime event for anyone-irrespective of democrats and republicans.
i feel this convention placed obana on the road to victory. people can nomore tolerate bush-cheny-mccain trio to go on with their faild exxonian policy based on falsehoods and lies (to inflate big boss's purse at the cost of general public) for four more years.

abdur azad, new york

Earth to Carl:

Another bizarre opinion piece from you. What are you watching? Your anti-Clinton articles seem to be written in a vacuum – you seem to twist the facts to suit your pre-disposed opinions.

Well I know McCain's detailed economic plan and that is more than enough for me to vote for Barack Obama.

All those women that are angry at Obama because Hillary did not win. Will it make any sense to vote for Bushccain after eight years of struggle?. If an african american can win the nomination a women can also be nominated. Please ladies wait your turn and vote for change.

I too am stunned and amazed at how well the convention is going! There are still a few Hillary stragglers out there that will not accept what the Clinton's themselves have...Barak Obama is the nominee and we need to elect him...period! But they must know in their heart that they are denying the truth...and denying that they also can take the initiative to learn more of what it is they say they don't know about Obama. Be honest with yourself...and listen to Hillary, we all respect her just as much as you who supported her in the primary...now let's move on united!

This is the time, now, to win back what is ours with someone new. Someone who inspires you with hope, not someone who will try to control your thoughts with fear like the current crew in power.

And now, the Republicans have put forth an old man who can't even check his own email and are expecting him to make the bold changes necessary for our survival? Paaaallllleeeeeessssseeeee!!! He'll be babblin' like Reagan did at the end of his illustrious 2nd term...senile with the wife running the place! Geeze!

Sorry, got to call it as I see it...and electing someone who requires a nap every day is not my idea of the best chance for change!

Mark

I think that Clintons are so much generous to Obama, that he should be thanking them for long time. His campaign insulted Mr. President Clinton too much, they insulted Hillary so many times, and both gave him their support. If he will not show any respect and gratitude, he is not what he is trying to sell.
Clinton is wonderful, magical person. I cannot use different word to describe him. Hillary was so radiant, and smart, and wonderful. They raised this absolutely amazing Chelsea....

Obamas have a lot to learn. They are coming with many issues on their backs already, be it class, be it politeness and respect to female candidate, respect to people, be it the real readiness to lead and make fast and right decisions. They need to learn to genuinely love other people of all races and classes. All this hype was rather hurting them than helping in my eyes. They have these 2 adorable girls, they do care for them, they need to protect them more = not to expose them too much to public....

Clinton has such a charisma, such a elegance in his behavior, how he greets people, women, men. He has the highest class. So is Hillary. And Chelsea is such a sweetheart, angel.

On the end, if Obama elected, I only hope he will make it well, he will be fair to all, he will care for all, no discriminations, I hope he will be able to raise this country back to better, and protect us all.... quite difficult task....

Mccain -> McSame -> McInsane –> McShame

Carl; Please do us a big favor, and stop writing trash about The Clintons. You reporters,or newspeople, or whatever the hell you are, are only doing this to keep the tension in the party. you make it so The Clintons are damned if they don't help Obama, and damned if they do. It is now Obama's turn to be a man and stand on his own two feet. It will be Obama and only Obama, who wins or loses The White House. It's his job, to make people want to vote for him. Not Sen. or Pres. Clinton, not anyone else. People are not voting for Michelle, or the kids, or the dog they might get. God do us all a favor and write stories, only about Obama and McCain.

hillary said and done what was expected of her and that makes me proud. what dosen't is the delegation that supported her caved in to the politically correct way of doing things in washinton and not supporting her at the nomination count, it is ovious to me that that was a socialistic monmination and not a democracy in action. just some more of politisions being politisions. don't get me wrong history was made today and that was a great thing, but i don't place my vote on history, race, gender or party, i base it on who as an american i think will do the best job, and with the 2 remaining candidates, although hillary and bill done there best to convince me, my vote has to go to mccain. Hillary in 2012.

Angela (6th commentator from the top), you and many other ignorant Americans would do well to actually listen to what a candidate says, or read the full text of the statement, not just the soundbites. Obviously guns and religions aren't all people such as you cling to. In this day an age of lack of intellectual curiosity, soundbites can be added to that list.

What people seem to be forgetting is that the president, in most cases, holds very little actual decision making power, it largely belongs to the houses. So if you are complaining about any number of a series of things that you believe are wrong, take a look at the senate and house of representatives. They are the individuals who pass the majority of legislation, regardless of whose signature is on it. In particular for a party supposed to be protecting the rights of the people, the warantless wire tapping went through with nary a scratch, including the vote from Obama. George may have signed it, but it passed both houses first.

Carl,

From what planet do you think the rest of the "thinking world" comes from.
You say what it is that you want to see and by any other definition that's how faith operates.
That I can respect.
But, Sen. Obama has NOT persuaded me and the masses that he has anything but his own "self interests" in mind. (Hmmm.. reminds me of Bill Clinton). I watched the Saddleback FOrum with great interest and Sen. Obama's display left me FULLY convinced that he does not have "the goods."

I think that Sen. Obama has more interest in being the first African American president then he does in being my president.

No thanks.
Unimpressed in Hawai‘i

I don't know how people are still divided between Hillary camp and Obama camp. Let's focus now, which direction our country is going? Those independent voters who were Hillary supporters, and now are going to vote for McCain just because he's a better man than Obama, how do they define him as a better man? It doesn't matter who will be the president, Obama, Hillary, McCain, Edwards, or others, the next American president should be someone who can lead us to better future than where we are now...

J.C. in L.A. makes a good point...the Clintons look like the leaders.

For everyone who thinks Obama is "in charge" of all this, needs to splash some water on their faces. Every move he makes is a "chump" move. Picking Biden was a chicken move. Going to Afganastan and play basketball with black soldiers was pointless. And giving a speech in Berlin about German history against Soviet oppression was downright bizarre. Incidently, 2 weeks after his slap in the face to the Old Soviet Union, Russia displays their military might in Georgia. Obama has the foresight of a teenager. The kind of mentallity which dares to test things. His arrogance of being able to handle things, makes him cavelier...and therefore dangerous. Cause and effect is not just some experiment done in a test tube. It is real, and has dire reprecussions.

I'm not a democrat, but Obama should have chosen Hillary. She had great support throughout the country and would have been a excellent VP candidate. The past 2 years of a democrat controlled Congress have really sucked... higher gas prices, pathetic illegal immigration policies, slumping economy, and many other problems. Think twice about voting a democratic ticket come November!

It is refreshing to read a thoughtful, considered piece of journalism. This election has revealed all of the worst aspects of our media–especially the constant absorption with petty, frivolous pseudo-scandals and the constant searching for "gotcha" moments. That is not journalism, it's sensationalism. In such an important election, people deserve better. Both candidates have put forward plenty of details about their policies and their plans. It's the media's job to analyze and ask questions, and help tell the public what we need to know.

Obama has been running for President for almost 2 years; it may be greater then 2 years.

He has wasted time because he ran this "change" campaign strategy to make HRC look obsolete. It worked enough to barely win.

Looks like Obama wants to still run on platitudes and talk about how he is personally being smeared.

Obama is running on empty.

We're doing a great job uniting. The Democratic party is getting stronger and stronger and I think the Republicans are starting to really panic again. All of us... Hillary, Bill, and all supporters together will make sure Obama becomes the next President of the United States!

Obama-Biden 08!

"Bill and Hillary Clinton have saved Obama" – how can a speech save someone? How would they have even been allowed to speak unless they support Obama? These conventions are like watching a sports event where everyone already knows the outcome. A bunch of cheering over nothing, a bunch of free network TV time. And now tomorrow night we get to see the prince riding his horse thru Mile High to the ooohs and aaahs of 75,000 kool-aid drinkers, a large percentage of whom are voting for Obama just to feel politically correct. People act like this guy is a savior yet his rhetoric has no substance.

It is very great convention. I am not registred democrat. But I loved all what was said at the convention. Bill Clinton , John Kerry,, etc...It was amazing.
I will vote for Barak Obama and Joe Biden. They are the people I wanted to see them at the white house. Good job demcorats

Joe Biden... knocked it out of the park!! He spoke the language of the American people and appealed to the average Joe not the political pundits. It was simple language. It is what average American's understand contrary to what the pundits say. Biden knows this and the pundits are over analyzing!

I love how George Bush is blamed for all the problems in America when the House and Senate have been controlled by the Democrats. Democrats are one thing, Radicals are something different. Obama is a radical with radical affiliations, no core values, and no true opinions. Pelosi and Reed are the best the Democrats have to offer in the House and Senate.

Higher taxes, more government control and more spending have never been a solution to economic problems and never will.

I now kind of wish Hillary would have beat Obama because this guy is scary. More of the same will be far better than a democracy turned to socialism destroying all the fundamental principles this country was founded on.

When are we going to hear the democrats remind America of Hurricanr Katrina and how Bush lied about weapons of mass destruction?

I voted for Bush twice (I'm sorry). I will vote for Obama in 2008. I believe that we do need to fundamentally change the direction and tone in our country. Second, I think Obama with a strong democratic congress will make many of the necessary changes (i.e., universal healthcare, etc.) to strengthen our country for years to come.

As for McCain it's pretty simple. There are three reasons not to vote for McCain:

1. He's too damn old (come on, he's older than Reagan)
2. He was wrong about Iraq, and continues to be a follower (not a leader)
3. He doesn't understand the economy, hell he doesn't even get the internet and the important role technology plays in our world today.

Last, I'm tired of seeing the GOP 'talk' about a big tent only to parade a bunch of white men over 50 as "our" representatives. It's time to send Bush-Cheney-McCain packing (bye, bye)!

I have been 100% for McCain, and watched the Clinton speeches the last two nights to pick them apart.

I am astounded – what incredible messages, If 50% of what they are saying about Obama is true, he is the clear choice for America at this time (I'm not rich and I'm about to lose my home), but I want to hear what Obama has to say tomorrow night – Republican bashing or aggressive solutions...???

I've seen so many blogs – I'm finally going to say it

Shut your mouth and open your ears. Prejudice has no place in this world. Not now. Not in the future.

STOP THE HATE. Vote one way or the other. Just STOP THE HATE.

John Kerry and Joe Biden could learn a thing or two from the Clintons about class and loyalty. Their attacks on John McCain made me sick. Too think the John McCain stood up for John Kerry when he was swiftboated-and now he is swiftboating McCain. That is dishonorable-and I don't ever want to hear that blow-hard Biden refer to McCain as his "friend" he is a partisan hack who doesn't deserve to be in McCain's company. Discusting-and a big turn off to independents!

Kudos to the Clintons for showing character and integrity in doing what's best for America. Barack Obama has once again proven to me that he can work miracles! He is the ultimate uniter. He was able to create a high-impact, positive convention that was supposed to be a disaster by all predictions. He ran the best organized campaign in history. He has already improved America's favorablility ratings internationally. An amazing American and proud to have him represent us. Obama '08/'12.

Thank you Carl,
Finally an intelligent assessment. I went from loving CNN to hating their obsession with the Clintons. I wanted to scream, "this is not about the Clintons!'" Tuesday they actually went to commercial at the beginning of the keynote speech! Your perception and perspective is refreshing. I love how the whole convention has been all-inclusive building to what should be an awesome crescendo. Most of the reporters are missing the essence of "change" and the historic symbolism. "We the people", are about to embark on a great journey to reclaim our inheritance.

This is the story of the 'Emporers New Clothes' re-told. Never in the history of American politics has someone so unworthy been given so much adoration as Obama. I wish people would stop reading the Holywood script and research the real Obama story of backstabbing in Illinois to underhand tactics in the primary to recent major opportunist flip flops. The Dems are not fit to govern the way they have behaved this year.

there is a difference between arrogance and confidence...

As a woman who is in a bi-racial marriage (happily), I was quite torn in who to vote for in the primaries.
Hillary's speech last night did conjure up feelings of 'what if.'
The bottom line is this... Joe Biden is right. It does cost me $60 to fill up my Saturn. Just this month we learned the electric bill, the gas bill, the phone bill and the day care bills are ALL going up next month.
I appreciate all that Obama may lack, but I just don't see how this country can continue on it's current path.
President Clinton was dead-on when he said in 2001 we finally got to see the Republican Party's ideas come to fruition.
The last 8 years have done much to harm our economy and our place in the world.
My sons are Americans living on Earth. They will one day be Americans who are contributing citizens to our world.
The time is now, we need to change direction.
The Democrats are what we need right now.

The number 8 in the Bible represents New Beginnings and in the year of 08 we are seeing a new beginning. God is doing a new thing in the earth and it does not matter what you think and how you try to spin it. Barak Obama will be the next President of the Free World. But the real truth is all of you Hillary & Bill lovers were never going to vote for Barack and you never will. So, take your angry votes and whining on over to the dark side.

Great speech by everyone... I watched at home and believed I got a good sense of how it must have felt to be there... I was very emotional......
I am proud to be an AMERICAN... GO OBAMA....YES WE CAN!!!

America is learning what Obama Supportors have known all along, that Obama is the Best Candidate!!!

Obama has the Morals, Honesty, and Judgement to do what is Right For America!!

I'm hoping and praying that those of you who are 'Hillary supporters' and now saying you're going to vote for McCain don't really call yourselves democrats. How could you possibly say you supported Hillary Clinton and her policies then turn around and say you support John McCain, who believes in the exact opposite?! She herself has asked if her supporters have been supporting her or what she stands for. If you actually support what she believes in you would also be linning up to support the Democratic nominee. To say you want to support another term or HORRIBLE leadership is SO HYPOCRITIC and Hillary herself does not agree with you!

DNC is trying too hard to make a sell on Obama. He is not ready I see and hear green when it comes to Obama. Too bad blacks are in such a hurry to elect a Black President they sold out their country for an inexperience candidiate over a great candidate. Bush and Obama have a lot in common they ran on similar platforms change and they could work across party lines...both had little to no experience...and both have major ego issues..look what that combination got America..Amercia does not learn from their mistakes...take the guy they like over a candidate who could actually do the job...

It was obvious the Hillary thought she was entitled to the nomination of the DNC but she didn't win it – for a variety of reasons. That's the way campaigns go. But she gave a brilliant speech, as did Bill, and whether or not there is a love/hate relationship between Clintons/Kennedys/Obamas – it doesn't matter. Obama is the nominee and I think the convention has been an effective start to his campaign. I'm ready for a more thought-driven president – one with a vision – instead of a knee-jerk, spasmatic war monger who wants the status quo and has no vision of our children's tomorrow in this country.

Mr. Bernstein let me commend you on a thoughtful, insightful piece and I agree with you completely. Jim Carville thinks Obama is way off-base hear.....that he needs to be serving up big platters of red-meat and going on the attack big-time!!! I disagree...yes, he's going to have to counter many nasty, slimy under-handed attacks by the GOP (after all, that truly evil Karl Rove is hovering in the shadows pulling strings...of Steve Schmidt in particular...) but in terms of his own message and controlling that message he's doing an exemplary job. Maybe we need to wrap our heads around the fact that a new era in American politics has dawned and Senator Obama is responsible for that. I'm a Canadian, Mr. Bernstein, but never in my 48 years have I ever been so consumed with an American election and its outcome. Never...because it's never been more important. The last eight horrendous years have reduced a powerful, incredibly well-respected nation (world wide) into a despised, I dare say loathed country because of Dubya and his nefarious cabal and I truly believe, in my heart-of-hearts that Obama and Biden can restore that credibility, that respect back to the White House, back to Washington and back to the country as a whole.
McCain would make it worse...and it can't afford to be any worse than it already is.......it just can't. Thanks for your insight, Mr. Bernstein.
Don in Toronto, ON. Canada.

We were crying, laughing, cheering clapping all night long. For a moment we were proud to be American.....and we are Canadian, so we can only imagine what you, as Americans, felt. If Obama and the Democrats can convince us through the TV in another country, November 2008 should be your year. I am an American Politics Junkie and CNN has been on my TV for days (just ask my 16 yr old son) and I have been following this election since the first Primary in January. I am so impressed by BOTH your top two candidates, Clinton and Obama. Do you even realize how lucky you are to have this enthusiasm? We love our country but if you really love politics Canada does not do it quite the way the USA does and we should. Hillary and Bill showed class above class with their speeches. Perhaps there was a rift but they have risen above it with grace and style. I happen to be an Obama fan from the start so this nomination was amazing and I will always remember the glance you allowed me into what will certainly be a shining historical moment for African Americans, for woman and for the USA. I can't wait to see what is to come.

The Obama Campaign is a FRESH start for Politics! Out with the Old, In with the new!

Obama/Biden 08

I think it is pathetic the way the Clinton's have sold out for the sake of political gain. Both Bill and Hillary have made it clear that they do not believe Obama has the skillset to be an effective President and they reiterated that opinion throughout Hillary's campaign and yet they are now endorsing him? Did he somehow become qualified over the last few months? Of course not. Obama still lacks the experience and understanding needed to be President and the Clinton's know it but Bill and Hillary are willing to ignore the damage an Obama presidency will wreak on this country because they are so focused on attempting to salvage their position in the party. I suppose I can understand that to a degree but the Democratics have clearly written them off – they were more than willing to humiliate them with their public support of Obama during the campaign so the Clinton's attempts at walking the party line are simply pathetic and will only serve to undermine their credibility with the American people. Obama hasn't given them the time of day and everyone knows it – how can they just ignore it? It's too desperate and very sad.

Great article.

I have to admit that the Clinton's surprised me during this convention. I am not, and have never been, a fan of the Clintons. I thought Bill did alot of wrong to this country. And I think Hillary ran a bad campaign and was on the wrong side of many of the issues. It is because of the Clintons that I have never voted for a Democrat for the President of the United States. Instead, I have voted for 3rd party candidates that uphold the values of the Democratic Party. I voted for Nader in 2000 and was proud of it. I still am.

But Barack Obama has restored my faith in the party in the country. I am equally proud to be voting for him in November.

The Democratic Party does not need former Hillary supporters that think John Mccain is right for this country. Good riddance.

I want to know the background of my president; who is he, where did he live, what were his mom and dad like, did he fish, did he hunt, play football... I want his character more than anything.

To the poster who wrote below:

"Obama, preaching unity and change, failed to unify his OWN party prior to the convention; that’s egregious and unacceptable."

You have got to be kidding? You say that Obama failed to "unify his OWN party" Don't you mean Hillary failed to unify? Didn't Hillary hold out till the end with her crew of whiners? Didn't she refuse to take down the barriers of the primary?

Come on, get real. Obama has had to treat her and Bill Clinton with warm baby blankets and tender loving care. She/They have hurt the Democratic party and put it in terrible risk.

Obama has to clean up her and Bill Clinton's mess. But you know, Obama is up to the challenge and READY TO BE OUR COMMANDER IN CHIEF.

Carl,
I've always respected your political and journalistic sensibilities, and this tome does nothing to diminish that respect. I agree that Obama needs to do those things that you set out so clearly. So why, even after he does all these things, am I not the least bit excited about the campaign or the election? I truly thought that the Joe Biden choice was a masterstroke, but I'm still having trouble getting the fire started. Am I alone in my dismay? Am I the only one who tonight thought " Damn, Clinton could run again RIGHT NOW and beat everybody in the race?" Where's the passion, outrage and clarity of purpose that he invoked? I'm at a loss.

I'm hearing some Hilary supporters say there voting for McCain anyway?? That just meant you never stood for what Hilary stood for. The GOP cant fight a clean fight but you see Obama he keeps doing him. I'm sick and tired of the BULLSH!T that you lame ass fake democrats say your not voting for OBAMA cause he is no fit for the position. I guess a slumping economy, 10 billion dollar a month war, borrowing money from the Chinese is what you want from a president. It's very clear to me that its experience VS change and experience has taught us all its time for a change. I'm looking forward to Obama becoming president cause LORD knows we cant take another 4 years of this economic crisis

i am a diehard hillary supporter, aside from bill, and i have made my first donation to the obama camp. thanks to hillary

Being a staunch Republican, it has become clear Carl, that this country is headed in the wrong direction under 8 years of the boy from Texas. It is also clear that the media has decided to statistically skew polls in an attempt to maintain interest in the campaign. Walk down the street Carl, there is hope in their eyes. Blab away until Nov. 4th, but Obama will win by a landslide mandate for change. If there are truly 50 million Americans stuck in ignorance in this country and elect McCain, Canada will have the a historic percentage of application for citizenship. Why would you stick around? This is the big one folks, this is your once in a lifetime chance to truly elect a man who will have a memorial built ala Lincoln 100 years from now. If you can not see through your own prejudices, then you are pitied.

JC-Los Angeles : "Obama, preaching unity and change, failed to unify his OWN party prior to the convention; that’s egregious and unacceptable."

Thats because ignorant and stubborn people like you cannot think beyond your blinded support for clintons. Americans are sick of clintons.

Clintons are the biggest liars and hypocrates, and we all witnessed that.. On the front talk about unity and backstab later. Such pathetic losers..

If McCain is such a great leader, Is his experience better than George W. Bush who is the president. McCain had a chance to run but backed out for the Bush machine. Mr. McCain has waffled on various position such as the 100 year war.. I am concerned that he will say anything to be president. So I don't know about his honesty. I don't know about these polls, but most Americans I meet at work, on the street and play want Obama.

Sadly, it takes a long article to try and explain to us that Senator Obama and his campaign/convention is about him and the "change" we all want to see and hear. Not the change from oil, war, the poor economy and the republicans to a different, more promising future based on specific plans and action but the reluctant change from the popular and powerful Clintons to him. Senator Clinton lost and Senator McCain and the republicans will win this election because of it; the Kennedys never liked the Clintons and their endorsement of Senator Obama proved it (now that's a wicked sense of humor). I'm impressed with Senator Obama and think he talks a good game but there's just too much at stake with the war on terrorism to entrust someone who has virtually no foreign policy experience and now is not a good time to elect someone with training wheels. People forget about 9/11 too quickly. Book your next family vacation to Pakistan, Iran, Iraq or Afghanistan and see for yourself what awaits your children's future; I don't like it anymore than you do but that's the reality of it. It's not Hollywood or a video game but this convention would qualify as both if you asked me.

I guess you guys at the republican war room are banging your little fingers on your keyboards to respond here like crazy right now in an effort to make it seem like we, the REAL viewing public, can't see just what your doing...

Be advised that we can see right through it.

I guess the sour grapes you eating right now are making you a little bitter.

Your games don't work anymore, your just starting to look foolish.

Watch it, your fear is showing.

and by the way... your puma "plants" are really funny to watch. I got a real kick out of them. Hilarious.

The change Obama/Biden '08 offers, has my vote.

joseph gregory, to your comment about BO being as you say "arrogant people in power are dangerous" I guess John and Cindy both who never had to work in their life. Someone who stole drugs and served no jail time. Someone who has servants to help run their 7,8 or 11 homes is safe because they are the common family?

Well someone owes me a few more houses and some servants!

It doesn't matter whether you like Obama or not, the fact is George Bush and McCain and the Republicans mustnot win this election. This country cannot take another four years of the dishonesty of the Republican mentality. Even though McCain may be an honorable man(?), he backed George Bush and the miserable war in Iraq where so many youngmen and women died for an undetermined reason based on lies.

It will be a glorious moment for America when a Black candidate is elected as President.It will move America far ahead and far away from the underlying racism in this country. It will prove to the world that Americans are able to look past ethnicity into a man's heart and determination to make this country a better place for everyone.

It has to be Obama or we are doomed as a country that can lead the world again. It has to be Obama or we will continue to dived the people into groups that cannot work towards a humanity that believesin the inherent right of all individuals as equal. It has to be Obama because he represents what we need to be in the sight of others around the world.

"JObama 08" – Change we can believe in.....what a scary joke! We all saw what 8 years of necon extremism & inexperience did for the country, and now people want to vote for left-wing extremism & inexperience? Aren't there any better choices than this? I will not vote for "JObama" style socialism – No thanks!

The Democrat's attack on McCain as being a Bush clone are factual baseless. If you actual bother to research his voting record, McCain has differed from Bush on number of different issues. I'll take my chances with McCain – at least I know where he stands on things, and he'll only be a one term President anyway. No experience Barack & his Washington puppet master Joe Biden are suppose to be these great agents of change? The thought of such a radical left-wing socialist government in control for possibly 8yrs is scary to say the least – we might as well just kiss the Constitution good-bye and prepare for a socialist ran police-state w/ over 65% of our paychecks going towards federal taxes. This & the new "green economy" , which Al Gore & other prominent members of Democratic Party have a huge financial stake in, is suppose to save our country's economy? Sounds like pie in the sky nonsense to me.

Carl,

Great article! It has been an amazing trick bringing the party together, espicially after Hillary's speach last night and the response of her die hard fans. Ulitmately what this convention has been about is erasing the fears that many americans might still have about Obama as a leader and a person that is like us. I have NOTHING in common with Mcain, and to hear his view about the economy, health care, the war in Iraq, makes me realize he is compleletly out of touch. Obama needs to lay out specifics, but I think that voters would have to be insane that voted with bush 90% of the time. As SIR Charles Barkley so simply stated, if your rich and well of, it doesnt matter who is president, or you want more of the same policies. If your like me and most americans (struggling to make ends meet as costs skyrocket, no or not enough health care, and friends and families in a country they have no business being in) your probally thinking the same thing I'm thinking.... How much worst can Barrack Obama do? Throw up on a foreign leader? Led us to the brink of WW3? Ruin the economy? Oh..wait... Bush has already done all these things. Its time for some sort of change.

Cindy from Ga, first again I see. You say you want Obama to give specifics on where stands on the issues. He lays everything out on his website, just like John McCain does. The difference is, and you don't seem to get it, someone can have the best laid plans in the world, but if they don't have the respect or trust of the American people, there is no way to get that done. I don't trust John McCain. He tells us from one side of his mouth he is a maverick, that he beats to his own drum. Well, how do you explain that he has voted with Bush over 90% of the time during a FAILED 8 years, and that he voted against Clinton over 90% of the time in the 90's during a SUCCESSFUL 8 years. I don't trust John McCain to make my life better, to lift up the American people over the next 4 years, so I respectfully disagree with you.

To those that are skeptical about how well this convention has gone, or question where Obama stands, must not have been paying any kind of attention to any of the speeches.

They not only have successfully shown that McCain has poor judgment... when it comes to Iraq, his environmental policies, economic policies, and vision for the younger generations, but showed that Barack is exactly what this country needs.

Change means changing ourselves. Changing our perspectives. Changing the economy. Changing the world's perspective. Paying attention to the middle class that is struggling under the Republican regime. This convention expressed all over Obama's means and ideas on how to successfully change this country for the better.

The republican's suffocated this country with their ego centric approach to politics. They care little for the people of this country and showed this every step of the way. Their unnatural need to cut taxes for the rich, give more to oil companies that have seen record profits is beyond me.

Obama is our President. He cares about people. He has the judgment to lead us out of the mess we are in.

Obama '08!

If some of the individuals making comments would search their hearts they would find a small amount of hatred for the man, is it because he is black?

Why shouldn't they clean it up, they messed it up.
Hillary lost!! when has the winner of the democratic party ever had to do what they demanded Obama do?

He won fair, history has been made and that was a lot for some egos to accept.
So shut up, stop winning and get a life

As a Independent I have overall been very impressed with this convention. I think Bill Clinton hit the ball out of the park tonight for Obama and has convinced me that I need to give Obama a serious second look as my choice for President. It is now up to Obama to turely convince me he is the guy to vote for.

Looking to next week's RNC assuming it doesn't get delayed due to the hurricane I can't help but wonder who they are going to have speak that will really help McCain. Bush Sr and Bush Jr followed by Chaney???? I can't help but wonder if next week will help Obama more then hurt him?

If the Clintons are such caniving, ruthless people why were so many at the Convention last night and again tonight giving them a rousing standing ovation? Hillary and Bill couldn't begin their speechs till the cheers subsided! Are all those thousands of people totally clueless? I dont' think so. I do think those who can't see what is so obvious to the rest of us are suffering from Bushwashing and Roveing lies.

Indeed they are orchestrateing an impeccable campaign through convention Carl. This evening i listed to the critiques offered by the GOP surrogates on Larry King Live... As I listened, i got the feeling that MCain and his cronies think that everything is just hunkey dorey with the american economy. That kind of delusional thinking is what will help the GOP to lose this election, regardless of what Obama and Biden do or don't do.... I think that McCain's surrogates need to be reminded that you can fool SOME of the people SOME of the time..

The disgruntled Clinton supporters need to get a life. To say they will vote for McCain instead of Obama because Hillary did not get the nomination is very shallow. These people are not true democrats but racist in disquise. They would rather simply vote for John McCain than to vote for a biracial candidate, even if he is the right choice to put this great country back on the right track., How many Republicans do you think will will vote for Barrack Obama if John McCain does not choose Mick Romney as his running mate. The answer is zero.

I am mystified. Obama is a junior US Senator who has yet to complete his first term in office. He has negligable business experience and no military experience. What qualifications does he posess to assure the health of the world's largest economy, act as Commander in Chief of the military forces of the United States of America, and lead the free world against the forces of tyranny and chaos?

It saddens me to see the bitterness of some of my fellow women in this blog. I am a firm Hillary supporter, but I am obviously going to vote for Obama over McCain. It would be a slap in the face to Hillary to elect a man that will work to undo everything she has worked so hard for. Please think about the big picture here...think about the Supreme Court and how Row V. Wade will be overturned if McCain is elected. Think about our troops over seas. Are we going to keep them in harms way because we feel slighted? Are we really going to elect the wrong man out of bitterness? Sometimes things are bigger than us. Would I prefer to be voting for Hillary...of course. But with the nation being at such a pivotal point, I can't vote with my anger.

Obama now...Hillary in 2016

I have to say that the Clintons really stepped up the past two nights to support Obama. I have always respected both of them so much and am glad that they have kept my admiration.

I am so tired of those Clinton people who insist that they are going to vote for McCain rather than Obama. The two candidates couldn't be more different. I personally couldn't stand four more years of the Republican reign. McCain would just be four more years of the same.

McCain doesn't give a darn for women's rights and will do nothing but appoint conservative supreme court appointees. That would be a disaster to us all.

I say wait until tomorrow night and let Obama make his case. I think that everyone will be pleasantly surprised. I think he will definitely lay out his agenda. Also I am very happy with Joe Biden. He will be a big asset to Obama. Obama will surround himself with excellent advisors and will listen to advice which I doubt that McCain will do.

I absolutely love Senator Clinton's speech. I believe all Hillary supports that are leaning to voting for John McCain listen to her speech again. Ask yourself, are you voting for the woman or what the woman stands for? Also, what I like about Obama, he does not claim he can do it all. In fact, he clearly says that it's WE that will do this together, not just him. Hillary supporters, please don't throw away our future by voting for John McCain.

Supporters of both Obama and Clinton need to stop their mutual attacks on one another. That fight is over, and it's time to move a head. Continuing this discussion serves only to exaggerate the heartfelt but misguided emotions of a small contingent of our party, and plays right into the hands of the GOP (who, I'm sure, have more than a few plants in these boards to stir up trouble).

One nation. One party. One choice for president. Let's put this thing to bed in November.

The Clinton's have not saved Obama. They've saved themselves. Up until the last couple days, their legacy has been diminishing due to their own comments and actions... due to their own desire to make history of their own. If Obama loses this election, the blame will be shared by all of us, not just the individual at the top of the ticket. I am a proud supporter of Obama, but, above all, a proud Democrat. Frankly, I would have been happy with either Obama or Clinton, or Biden for that matter, at the top of the ticket. They are each strong individuals and strong leaders, and they all have the credentials to successfully lead this country out of the mess it's been left in these last eight years.

I wish some of my fellow Democrats would stop whining and wake up... it's time to make a change in this country. Obama is now our only chance for real change in the next 4 years. And to those who believe he has yet to give any specifics, you should get off your couch or your chair and get out there to meet him. I've seen him twice now and each time he set out not just his ideas and goals, but his plans on how we can actually reach those goals and make this nation a better place for all of us.

Bill & Hillary Clinton saved their own politacal legacy and any future chances for Hillary to run for President by setting aside the vineyard of sour grapes that they were trying to cultivate in the mind of their digruntled supporters.

Somebody gave them a wake up call and America will gain from reality, finally, prevailing.

They got over it and we all can breathe a little more easier.

Their selfishness and almost put this country in a position of having to endure four more years of Republican mediocrity in stead of progress and meaningful change under an inspired Obama administration.

That is the truth of it!!!!

Yes, easing the Clintons off center stage will be a Herculean feat! Losing that primary will be a bitter pill to them for years to come. They learned the hard way that bitter infighting among the inner circle got them nowhere. But for goodness sake, why this continual sense of entitlement they both subscribe to? What they are seeing is that American politics are moving beyond them. Even if one is a Clinton supporter, we can do the math. Twenty years of the American presidency run by two families is just too weird!

Well the majority of democratic america has spoken, I am 48 yrs old I grew up in Florida and reside in Alabama and i can truly say America has made a positive change in race relations some people just dont understand that most black americans my age did not belive that this would happen in our lifetime. We (americans)should be very proud of ourselves we have come a long way in human relations taking that chance to allow ourselves to trust without reservations of race, may God continue to bless America with strong persistent people that fight for the greater good, with out them this moment would have never happened thank you Jesus we love you

Obama supporters sound like folks that have never been in charge of anything, never built a business, and never had to unify people of differing viewpoints to work together toward a common goal. And he is a perfect reflection of them.

He has no executive experience. He sounds like kids in high school running for ASB President – I promise candy for lunch, no more homework, more days off, etc. – making promises that sound like wonderful ideas but can never be fulfilled because the candidate has no real world experience. Did Obama hire a bright, top of his class, recent graduate from Harvard Law to head his campaign? No, he surrounded himself with experienced hands to guide him. Do average Americans who are not committed liberals want to put someone in charge of the world's largest economy, the most powerful military on earth and greatest model of liberty in history? No. Because people who understand how the real world works, with it's tough decisions and meaningful consequences, those people realize that Obama's ideas are not grounded in the wisdom that comes from having to make those decisions and live with their outcomes.

This would be cool – if Obama took the podium on Thursday night, thanked the crowd for their confidence in him, then, in a moment of true selfless service and humility, admitted he wasn't ready for such high office and gave the nomination to Biden or Clinton. But, that's not going to happen. So, we are stuck with the promising rookie vs the grizzled veteran in the race for the Oval Office.

Come November, more people will end up pulling the lever for the experienced guy. I sense McCain is going to win, and it won't be as close as people want to pretend it will be. Regardless of what happens, Obama's nomination is a historic moment.

No One talks about Obama's achievement...his resume is so thin that no one at the convention talked about it.

I am not ready to vote for a president that has as much experience as I have and is about the same age as I am.

I think age matters and presidency is not fit for younger crowd. Look, at Clinton and Kennedy both were young and both of them were very busy going after women. Both of them were failure at foreign policy. Remember Somali, Haiti and first World Trade Center bombing? What was Clinton accomplishment in these areas?

Wake up G.B. Etheridge.

What part of the last 8 years did you miss.

Under the Clinton administration we actually came up with a surplus.

The difference between the Democrates and Rebublicans is that the Republicans spend more money and they spend it overseas. Democrates invest within the US and because of this investment, we receive the benifits and able to generate a surplus.

If you look at the both Bush's administrations and the Regan administrations, look at the rise in our trade deficit.

Reducing taxes did not reduce government, they spent more.

And in what programs they did reduce in the USA, it caused Enron, our housing crisis, Bears Stern.

You are a person who must prefer to have 2 dollars in your pocket instead of 1 even though a gallon of milk 20 dollars instead of 3.

Wake up America!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I've seen many elections in my day, but none have been as spirited or polarizing as this one – although the last 2 came very close.

I'm an Independent, and although I didn't vote for Hillary, I was impressed with both Bill & Hillary's speeches this week and I'm grateful to them for being so gracious at this time when we ALL need to unite. They are both great politicians but I support Obama's new direction and pray his unique talent will bring us all together – citizens, congress & our administration, our allies and, yes, even our foe. I think Obama & Biden will make a great team and will begin to put us back on the right track. I hope we will again have a trusted government OF THE PEOPLE and not of the corporations & special interests. But we have SO many challenges, I doubt that any one administration can do it all in 4 or 8 years. Let's hope we have more great politicians willing to take the next shift.

I personally have had enough of all the bickering and smear tactics – it's such a destructive waste of time and energy, and it prevents us from making the progress we all so desperately need. Our president is only one person on the team and he (or someday she) will need the talents and support of everyone willing to do their part to turn this ship around. We're all in this boat together, and right now it's sinking.

To Angela and Mary: wake up from your fantasy worlds. Neither the Clintons or Obama has ever claimed to hold resentments to the other. People like the two of you take it upon yourselves to assume so. You only needed to see Hillarys eyes to see the true jubilation she is feeling this historic week. I believe Obama has great things in store for Sen. Clinton.

The D.N.C. seems like a tight hollywood production, really waiting for some real issues like a tough energy policy to be taken on,very little talk about the one issue that is at the heart of all our problems. it's all about energy!!

To be honest, I'm just confused by the drama. I can't really see how anyone would vote for anyone or any party that even vaguely resembled or sounded like the current administration. I find the current situation in our government so embarrassing and so badly botched I would sooner not vote at all than vote for a person who had any alliance with or allegiance to anything like the conservative politics my family's been enduring for the past eight years - how can anyone actually stand on two feet and say "I think me-for-myself trickle-down politics is going to work if we just try it via McCain"? How many more years do we need, really, to see that conservative politics and this fraudulent myth of "small government" just doesn't work in a country as large and economically and socially complex as ours? Well, as I say, I just don't see the need for the hoopla - it's clear Obama is organized enough and competent enough to at least pull us out of this mess if not get us going the right direction. These days, I'm an easy democrat and I don't know why I shouldn't be.

Carter, Clinton, Clinton, Gore, Kennedy, Obama.

Most of all, the convention makes me so proud to be a democrat. The leaders of our party have wisdom, intelligence, grace, spunk, humanity, and most importantly, gravitas. In this primary our choices are Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, not to mention early Al Gore chatters. All would make great presidents. We have heavy hitters at the top of our party, conducting serious business of the people.

It has been an uplifting convention so far and I look forward to tomorrow night. The bar has been set very high but I am confident that our candidate will clear it.

Carl,
right on. I agree that Obama has displayed incredible leadership quality in running his campaign, defeating the Clintons (why are they such sore losers?) and in articulating and actually building, a new coaltion of Americans. This is leadership.

Policy details? They'll come but let's not get too hung up on this. That is what the cabinet is for and the bureaucracy. He needs to articulate the vision, the new direction. The American President is called a 'leader' not a 'managing director' for nothing.

When Obama comes on stage, there is energy, energy, energy! Suddenly the place lights up! He wants to lead, is ready to lead and will lead the country in the right direction. With Joe Biden at his side, we could hardly ask for more. Plus we are getting his mega-watt smile as a freebie!!

You've given a thoughtful, insightful analysis of Obama's convention
and I do believe you have a handle on the mindset of the next president. Behind every event at the convention there's been a carefully orchestrated process that's been put in place to build up the momentum for the finale, as well as cover any contingency. Obama is a masterful organizer and leader. He's surrounded himself with experts in the field, has given them all their missions and has sent them out to do their (his) thing within his discipline. Case in point, Obama's supporters were really able to stroke Bill's ego with all their continuous applause. Everyone so far has hit their marks and delivered the goods. Now it's Obama's turn to wrap it up. I hope he didn't set the bar too high.

Thank you, Carl. Good job!

I'll take my chances with the young bi-racial man with the open mind and heart from Hawaii who moved to the mainland to feed his hunger to learn, pursuing the degrees and credentials he needed to make a difference in the world. I'll trust that young man who took his higher education and his multicultural life experience, and put those to good use on behalf of the less fortunate, and now, our nation as a whole.

McCain teetered through Annapolis, graduating in the very lowest rungs of his class. Education was unimportant to the party boy. Opportunities to learn were wasted on him. Other than his prominent military family and his looks, what did John McCain actually have going for him?

If he hadn't been a POW in Vietnam, where would McCain be now? Married to Cindy Hensley? Wealthy? A U.S. senator? Running for the presidency? Not very likely, is it? Nope. Not likely at all....

Wow, Obama deserves an Olympic medal of some kind. This convention has been one big crazy obstacle course and he and "Team Obama" has hit every target. Now he has a respectable chance...provided he gives the speech of his life tomorrow.

I can't help admiring the Clintons despite myself. They would have made wonderful Roman emperors 2,000 years ago!

I don't understand why people say Obama is arrogant. He worked as a community organizer with the poor for gosh sake's! McCain and his wife are millionaires who want to give tax breaks to all of their rich friends and have no interest in tax breaks for the people who really need it, or national health care. Do they think Obama is arrogant because he went to Harvard? Don't we want one of the most intelligent and moral people in the country to run the country? Someone who really worked for their money rather than having it handed to them on a silver plate? Isn't working for what you have the American way? It's what makes this country so great!!

At any rate, I guess all of the attack ads are doing their business, or else Jon Stewart is right that people would rather have someone average than someone intelligent as president because they'd rather have an imaginary pal than a real leader.

I think Hillary is a great politician and will certainly be voting for her if she comes around again. But if you were a Hillary supporter and cared about any of the issues she cared about: universal healthcare, women's rights, stopping this ridiculously overexpensive war when our own economy is suffering... and you are voting for McCain. Well, at least a Republican voting for McCain is doing it for the right reasons. Hillary's an intelligent woman too and she wanted and still wants the country to go in the right direction! Don't be one of the "personality voters" that got us into this Bush mess! The issues a candidate supports speaks more about their real personalities than an advertisement ever will.

The Bush and the boy have fumbled the ball so many times people have gotten use to it. They think American is suppose to be on the botten. Its been so bad for so long, many people have gotten use to it

Its time for a big change. Could not be any worst that it is now

Obama has the vision and the good judgement to make the right calls.

Last night was magical. The greatest President of our generation Bill Jefferson Clinton was incredible!. Thank you Mr Clinton, you were fantastic in your support for Barack Obama. Your speech was great, truthful, just awesome! You were there 100% behind Obama our next President of the United States.

Hillary you were fantastice.You gave your all for your support of Obama. You are a classy lady. Good example for allour daughters.
Joe Biden you were great with your beautiful family. You are going to
be a superb VP.

Obama/Biden, what a perfect partnership to lead our country.

I Love you guys.

I think that Bill Clinton over shadowed Obama at the convention. I think that the Democrats understand now that having John McCain in the White House to continue the policies of the last 8 years will be a devastating blow to America's prosperity. Obama is capable. However, can he rebuild America? No single person can rebuild the nation. What that person can do is enact the right policies that allow Americans to rebuild America. The work on the ground will be done by entrepreneurs, inventors, innovators, social workers, and educators. These in turn will allow people to find jobs, produce economic outputs, earn an income, buy and sell, raise the next generation, and carry out the activities of human society more prosperously.

Carl,
I wish that I could write as well as you do. Your message is succinctly put and lucid. I think you have hit on the four most important issues that Barack has to face. However, there is the overarching problem of race that won't refuse to go away. The youngins' may talk a good game about voting, but the polling booths reek of Bengay and Aqua Net. Until my mother's generation wins the gold medal in the dirt olympics, any black person, even a mulatto, will have a tough time succeeding in a national election. Perhaps the current ipod generation, can get off of their collective cans and join forces with the blacks and hispanics to turn the tide to get Obama elected. Until then, sadly, we may be forced into four more years of Republican dominance.

I think that it's going to take all Democrats together to make this Change that being chanted. I think they're off to a good start. Senator Obama should seal the deal that Senator Kennedy, his wife and the Clintons set the stage for. All of the speakers were moving the train down the track.

I'm glad the Democrats decided not to cut off their noses to spite their faces. It's time for a Change and make America an even playing field. Not by punishing the rich, but by celebrating them and strategically partnering with them to build a better America for all.

Is Senator McCain being a HYPOCRITE by getting the celebrity Danny Yankee to swing the Latin vote. I wonder what he will do with Danny Yankee after the election? Will he throw him away like a piece of tissue after he's done with him and what will he do with the Latin Americans after he's nominated?

The Republicans seem to use their money to viciously bully. Let the debates be the gentlemen's battleground, but let every man have his day. And shut the hell up when it's not your day or you will force an unnecessary fight. Stick with the issues.

I believe the Republicans are not being very sportsman like. They are fighting dirty, and that insensitivity to humanity is frightening. It translates, "if you're not with us. We will do anything against you. Non-negotiable." That's war talk, all the way and it's scary. Where is the peace that we need?

We have already had one inexperienced fool in the white house, why would anyone want to vote for another man who talk good, makes promices he does not keep and looks to his wife to run the show. At least Hillary has BALLS!

I was not impressed with the McCain bashing. McCain is not my choice, but I do NOT want another man in the Big House who talks pretty and sleeps on the job! McCain is a HERO!

It better be more than a talk about vision for change. He must tell us what he will actually be doing to bring about that change. Fluff time is over

I think the more interesting thing is that the candidate of CHANGE has picked a MORE of the SAME for vice president – white, male, washington establishment, no executive leadership, old time democrat. It just goes to show you that Obama like most politicians says one thing and does another.

Finally! An objective viewpoint on what actually transpired and the leadership Sen Obama has for his difficult tasks ahead.

Look, the Clintons weild too much power to have the nomination stolen from Hillary. Sen Obama is the real deal folks. The fact that he can communicate the vision should not be held against him. I think he's a get it done guy and I know he will work in a non-partisan way to move the country forward.

Mary and the other republican women who supported Hillary: your candidate lost. Your candidate lost early. Your candidate needs your help paying off the debt she raised trying to trash Obama. Now send your money to her you lost sheep. Your team lost!

Carl, Carl, Carl

Too bad Jackie Kennedy and John Jr. were not here. The rest of the Kennedy's would have heard from them. Isn't it a shame that the media could buy the "bill of goods" that Obama is trying to peddle. The United States missed a real opportunity for leadership w/Hillary; a shame that most of the male population couldn't get a grasp on women in leadership positions.

Hoping for more women being born to rectify this in four years.

Obama is by far a better speaker than Hillary and even Bill Clinton. Besides that, he is more intelligent than either and has a natural ability to inspire people with not only his words but his body language. The Clintons have attested to his power influence and as good as their speeches were, I guarantee Obama will deliver not only the best speech of this convention, but with the venue and the significance of this event, this speech will be remembered as the most dramatic and world changing speeches in history.
i wish I could be there.

I was spellbound by both Hillary and Bill Clinton's speeches. Together they have unified the Democratic party, NOT Barak Obama or any other speaker. Their speeches were unequivocal in their support of Obama, they went farther in their support then I ever imagined they would. Even in the crushing disappointment of Hillary's defeat, they both were gracious, powerful and uniting speakers, for the good of the Democratic party AND Barak Obama.

That said, both Barak and Michelle Obama should be ASHAMED of themselves. Michelle for looking like she's pissed at the world and wishing she were anywhere but where she was the nights of the speeches and Barak for not appearing at the convention until the last day. What could be more important then his being at the convention to continue uniting the Democrats? If Barak Obama thinks this is an example of how you act during your "shining hour", he's going to have to work much harder to get my vote. This sure doesn't dispell the "rock star" or celebrity personna he's said to have. Obama needs to show me he wants the presidency, not that he thinks its a done deal. I'm still undecided but time is running out. I need to see how Obama is planning on change, not just hear that he's the candidate OF change.

Carl,

I disgree with you on many points. First, Obama' big EGOOOOOOOOO is going to crash and send him back to be a Senator.

Bill and Hillary Clinton have saved Obama and they did more than thier share. If Obama wants to win, it is up to him now. Bill & Hillary shouldn't be on the Campaing trail working for him, because at the end when Obama looses this election, they are going to blame Bill and Hillary. Enough is Ennough.

Joseph G: Have you seriously not noticed that everyone who has ever run for president is arrogant? You have to be arrogant in order to even run.

Hillary as VP? No. Joe Biden proved during his speech last night that he is the one for the job. Obama's selection had to do with who would be the best in the position, not who would 'guarantee a win.' Additionally, I highly doubt Clinton would have even accepted a VP nod.

Obama needs to giive a broad outline of his economic and foreign policy ideas and how it will be different from McCain's. No need for details as detail always changes when you negotiate with Congress or as the situation changes.

Carl. Well said. I always enjoy your commentaries and your inside knowledge of the Clinton's. I thought Biden and Bill were great last night and the convention's message is coming through loud and clear. I was a Hillary supporter early on, but the primary proved to me who the real leader is in the Democratic Party..Obama. The simple fact that he has been in control of his campaign from the get go and what they have accomplished in all 50 states is remarkable. A true leader surrounds himself with people who are experts in their areas and listens and analyzes before making any moves or decisions. That coupled with his brillant intellect and knowledge of the Constitution is exactly what this country needs..and none to soon. What the Republicans have done to the United States, in every area imaginable, is tragic and unacceptable. How anyone can consider voting for McCain is not paying attention. Obama/Biden 2008!!!!!

I had my doubts about how the Clintons would handle their huge role in the convention given the divisive primary. Those doubts have been thoroughly laid to rest. Hillary and Bill Clinton have both hit all the right notes at this convention. Like many people I thought Hillary's name on the ballot for the roll call was potentially divisive, but then through a masterfully orchestrated move, she turned it into unity inspiring bit of theater. Well done. Their speeches were also excellent. The Clintons have shown that they can put the division behind them and help the Democratic party win the Presidency.

It's too bad a few of Hillary Clinton's supporters can't let it go. If you like her that much, then listen to her. She's right. Obama's issues track closely with her issues. If you support what she stands for, then your only reasonable choice in this election is Barack Obama. McCain is the polar opposite. Don't vote against your own beliefs on the issues because you're angry about how the primary turned out.

Finally, stop buying the right wing talking point that Obama is an arrogant elitist. On what basis? It's just not there. The GOP is doing everything they can to sell that line. They can't back it up, but they figure if they repeat it often enough, people will believe it. It's astonishing that a man worth tens of millions of dollars is calling the other candidate an elitist, the candidate who just finished paying off his school loans a few years ago, the candidate who graduated from Harvard and instead of taking a high paying, prestigious law position, went to Chicago and worked for the community.

Why dont all supporters, Barrack's and Hilary's save their energy to fight the opponent McCain, instead of tearing themselves apart? Listen to the leaders, UNITY ! God bless you all.

Democrats – It is now time to to fully unite. I thank Hillary and Bill for what they said during the DNC. I voted for Bill both times. The things that happened during his time soured me a bit. Some of the things he said during the primaries didn't help either.

Bill Clinton is not a racist and if anybody says so, they are totally wrong. That being said, his remarks didn't help (BTW – it was the media who actually started the racists stuff). The comments were just inappropiate.

Anyway, that was then, this is now. We need ALL Democrats to unite and get behind our candidate. No more bashing of the Clintons (I've been critical, but never bashed). Contine to show your support for Hillary, by supporting Obama, who's policies are more closely aligned with hers. Dems in '08.

At last, some perspective! The punditry has gone on and on and on about the Obama campaign ceding the convention to the Clinton's, not focusing on beating McCain, not enough "red meat", etc – but they don't seem to believe that he is not about "politics as usual"!

The Obama campaign was brilliant to allow the Clinton's to redeem themselves after a campaign that had tarnished Bill's legacy and put Hillary's future in doubt. They delivered brilliantly, and everyone was a winner. After Michelle's speech, who will believe (besides Karl Rove) that she doesn't love her country?

I fervently hope that it works, that he is elected in November – but whether he is elected or not, we can all look back and see that he didn't stoop to the mudslinging and attack politics that have characterized American politics for way too many years.

I understand that all the Hillary supporters wanted her as VP but Hillary is nobody's #2. She has a more important roll in America and it starts with the election of Barack Obama as President of the United States.

I like Carl Bernstein, but only people from Washington think choosing the Kennedy's over the Clintons was a smart move.
Teddy Kennedy is without question the greatest Senator maybe ever.but I don't think any generation has warm fuzzy feelings about Caroline.

Whether the Washinton insider like or respect the Clintons, I believe Bill Clinton could be elected again as president.

Wondering if Obama's problems with the polls are about his race or his issues with the Clintons won't help solve the problem. The problem is Obama, David Axelrod, and their campaign. Obama's campaign thought that Bill Clinton did not deserve signs. I am starting to believe the Obama folks are not just arogant, but stupid.

Everyone wants to rain on the parade.

The convention has been riveting and wonderful. Makes me happy to be an American, for a change. To anyone who says any differently, get a life!

To Hillary supporters, keep sucking on your lemons. If you don't get on board, you'll continue to give yourselves ample reason to keep sucking.

Hey Carl,
Why do you hate the Clintons?. It shows everytime you make a verbal or written commentary. Lighten up. Obama will not win this election.
Who will you blame then Carl..... the Clintons.

Cindy – I'd like to know what more of a plan you want from Obama. He's consisted given a very detailed plan for every single bit of his policy. Energy? It's there. Health care? It's there. Taxes? It's there. Do you know what John McCain's health care plan is? Do you know how he'll save Social Security? Do you know his energy plan beyond "drill here and drill now!" or his plan for improving homeland security or where he's at with the environment? There is one candidate who has a lot of work left to define his policy, and it isn't Obama.

Barack Obama is the Democrats' Dan Quayle. Imagine if the Republicans had picked a minority candidate with a similar resume; the shrieks of pandering and incompetence would wake even a drugged Sean Penn. Pretty face, little experience and no courage, as demonstrated by a patent inability to defy his own party or reach across party lines on any matter of controversy or importance. Great candidate for the high school debate team, but too terrified to actually meet with town hall gatherings with John McCain and answer unscripted questions from those gun-and-religion-clinging high school graduates that he so patronizingly seeks to save from their own bad tendencies. Working to solve our country's problems - and succeed!!! - will take both courage and cross-party compromise, not some gauzy call for unity and the silly notion that you'll talk the other half of the country and their representatives into adopting your agenda. Carl, he can talk the talk, but he's never shown a willingness or ability to walk the walk.

What makes Bernstien think Hillary was the "toughest democratic machine of modern times"? If she was so tough she would not have lost to a virtual political novice like Obama. Basically, I think voters voted for Obama in protest against Hillary who many could not stand to see as the nominee of the party. Now the democrats have nominated someone who lacks experience and keeps talking about change without giving any specifics. I think they basically blew an election they could have easily won. McCain is far from great, but unless he makes some embarrassing blunder during the debates I really can't visualize him losing this election. In fact, if he rides through election day without a major gaffe I think he will win the election by the largest margin since Bush I.

Everyone is going on and on about the wonderful speeches the Clinton's both made, how hard they are working to unify the party, and what all of this means going forward for the Dems.

I do have one question though, all of the things the Clinton's said during the primary run....the lack of experience....the inability to lead...that Obama is just not ready....

Were those the lies or is what they are saying now the lies? One of the things I think we have to look at in our leaders is having the courage of their convictions. Over most of the past year we have all listened to the Clintons badmouth Obama and Obama badmouth the Clintons. Suddenly, in the last month or so they are united and well shucks, we all knew Obama was the best man for the job all along.

So I have to ask, which statements were the lies? And, if you're going to lie half the time or when its convenient, how do we know when or if you aren’t lying? For me, neither makes a very good showing for our future President because along with every other "message" they are sending there is one underlying "message" and I believe among all of the rhetoric, this is the clearest message we have heard. And that message is, no matter what, I am going to have my way. Whether I have to lie, doubletalk, or waffle, it doesn’t matter, I will get what I want, and the American people are too dim witted to realize what I have done.

The Clinton years were filled with many of things, good and bad; one of the more embarrassing things we seem to forget is part of the Clinton lagacy is all of the scandal-gates. Perhaps this is the true legacy, starting off the Obama race with a Democratic staple; we can call this one liar-gate.

Obama is doing a good job with the convention. He could have remained bitter and stuck to religion and guns, but he gave alot of leeway to the Clintons to restore thier star among the party, but yet was able to keep the party focused on the future. Even those that disagreed with him on some policies could still find themselves included. McCain has been said to hold grudges for years, fitting for a sidekick to Bush who wanted to avenge his father and go after Sadaam. The bottom line is that when you look past all the promises and SPECIFICS, you vote for the fundamental ideals that lie behind what they're saying. The democrats are wanting everyone to get healthcare directly from the government, where as McCain is talking out of the side of his mouth by saying he's for increasing competition, which if he talked directly he'd be saying he would give money to the healthcare and insurance companies and hope that it will filter down to lower costs for the consumer. That's a policy that will pad the pockets of the CEO and the average person will pay twice, once in taxes and second in bills. That's not change. That's McSame.

The clintons did an excellent job convincing the skeptics that they are willing to put the interests of the country before their own. It was evident from their demeanor and active partcipation that they will lead the charge, marching in sync with Obama and Biden, against the flawed republican policies. I feel that this election will sadly come down to people's comfortability with having a non-white president. the vision, the policies, and the enthusiasm to bring change will take a back seat when the republicans and neo-cons will once again try to appeal to the countries deepest fears through innuendos, half-truth and blatant lies. I pray for the sake of our country's future and our children's well being that the American people reject such politics of fear and unite for our common national interests. God bless America

JC – Los Angeles

Is this your first convention. The nominee's do not appear at all – period. Until FDR , they didn't even make an acceptance speech. Obama shouldn't have needed to unify the party, if you are a democrat, when Hillary lost your allegiance should have switched to Obama. To say McCain is a centrist is totally wrong – he WAS a centrist perhaps would be phrasing it correctly. Any Democrat voting for McCain is delusional – he has become a Neo-Con full stop.

Sen. Joe Biden of Delaware set the stage for Sen.Barack Obama’s historic address as the Democratic presidential nominee by launching a heated attack Wednesday night tying Sen. John McCain to the his mentor George W. Bush. Now all voters are assured that they have the power to change the country’s direction. To all the Mc Cain supporters, you all know you better bring it. I do not say this to be mean so please do not let me anger you. But why stay loyal to high gas prices? Why forget all the brave soldiers that gave there precious lives for a war that should have never been waged in the first place. I personally feel that the Bush Administration in some ways committed a crime, they deceived the American people. You can't deny that Barack knows that he will continue to be under the microscope even after he is in office. I feel that he truly seeks change and I hope you will have the open heart to forgive yourselves for even thinking of taking a gamble on John McCain and four more years of Republican failures. People are angry because Obama has hope that includes our children's future and Why not? Our kids are the future, you see it's one thing to have to deal with the terrorist that want to attack America. But some of our kids right here in America are acting like terrorist on American soil. Walking around with guns, kids that are young as ten years old, Who are committed to gangs & violence, of all sorts of crimes that I do not even have to mention.
On the night the Democratic National Convention made Obama the African-American ever nominated by a major party, delegates erupted in thunderous cheers when Obama joined Biden at the conclusion of his speech accepting the No. 2 spot on the ticket. “At the start of Obama's surprize appearance. I said to myself wow! the slogan. The main slogan, that remains in my heart. Change does not start from the top down. It starts from the bottom up,” Obama

I'm a PROUD Native of Delaware, and I could care less that Biden is on the ticket. Don't forget that he voted AGAINST the use of force in the first gulf war, at a time when saudi arabia, jordan, and other arab countries wanted to stop saddam. Great job joe.

John McCAIN WILL win this election, just wait and see.

NOW I really believe that Bill and Hillary are with the program and I have contributed to retiring her debt. She and Bill did everything that could have been asked of them. Please, to really unite the party, do the same as a show of support for the incredible job they did.

I have never been a Hilary Clinton fan, but I must say I was impressed with the strength and dignity that she displayed both in her speech Tuesday night and on the floor Wednesday. She was phenomenal. And President Bill Clinton truly "hit the ball out of the park" last night with his positive remarks and faith in Obama because his came from someone who has held the Commander in Chief position for eight years.

I don't necessarily believe either the Democrats or the Republicans are good for the middle class, but I do believe that the Clintons have played a major role in unifiying the Democratic Party and that any Hillary Clinton fan who has decided not to vote for Barack Obama (whose political ideas are closely aligned with Hillary's) has made that decision based on their own personal bias'.

I would like to say congrats to Obama and the entire Democratic family. They have done nothing but prove themselves in this election. With them telling their story about their families and how they came about just lets us know that they have ordinary lives like we do. They too had to work for what they believed in and wanted to accomplish. I truly believe in Obama and I know he will lead all Americans on a great journey. Yes, many people think that he should have chose Hilary but trust him. He knows what he is doing and Hilary and Bill Clinton said so themselves. And we all know how well they did when in office. We will see change in America with him as our president. I’m sure of it.

For Obama to be elected, he needs to counter McCain's strong self confidence image and become an extremely convincing figure, that he has what it takes to deliver and execute his ideas. He needs to substantiate what he says with rationales and past achievements. He must show that his thinking, his experience, his ability to select good advisors counters big time McCain's attacks of lack of experience. I suggest that he find residents of South Chicago, who may have benefited from Obama's work there, to speak up. I would be careful not to promise everything for everyone. The Obama campaign must come out swinging and hard and now, or I'm afraid the Republicans will gain.

We cannot afford anymore taxes. He wants to raise them for his and the rest of the Dems special programs. He has a questionable character with his associates. Hes for abortion and that means live abortion ( thats just so nasty) He wants all these ILLEGALS to come in here and suck off the teets of the Gov. Which means again more
money taxed on me. Hes for more rapes, car jackings, loaded Emergency rooms, jails,molestations and the list goes on and on. Dems are known to increase taxes and to do what they want never listening to the people. The gov job is to protect and serve its people. And the Dems will get us into more trouble....We Legal American citizens want to continue our soverinity. WE ARE number one and are slowly losing it to other countries. Obama wants to talk to the enemy without preconditions. Hes not worried about the little countries, like Iran who is helping the insurgents in Iraq and who want to blow Isreal off the map and to cut off the Christians heads. Cuba, and vensuela. If Iran gets nukes not to worry. Sorry Obama I worry and all of us do. We need a military built up. Clinton did that by decreasing our protectors.

We love to bicker don't we? The fact of the matter is this, Both Hillary and Barak are the strongest presidential candidates this country has seen probably since Bill ran in 1992, they clobbered each other in the primaries but now the votes were tallied and the primary conceded, its over. We are in tough times right now, and I do not think we can afford 4 more years of the same politics of the republican policy and they will pull out all stops and do everything to divide us. there is too much at stake here, with the exception of Bill Clinton, republicans have reigned since the 60's, I think its time for a new democratic reign with new progressive thinking.
go JoBama08!

Obama will have to WORK to win the election. He's got a lot to do to win my vote. I don't vote along party lines, although Bill Clinton and Al Gore stated their positions clearly, gave information that made it easy to vote for them. How can I vote for someone who calls the middle class "christians carrying guns"? He says he is the CHANGE candidate. He needs to change his views about the middle class. What's he going to change & how does he think he's going to get it done? What is his plan? This country is made up of the lower and middle class. The rich, while holding the power, are fewer in number. Unless he does a LOT better job in the next days and weeks, I will be staing home on election day.

There is so much talk about Obama not having a plan, and that he doesn't stick to the issues. Are we following the same election? Do me a favor and check out barackobama.com and you will see plans and issues addressed. So many people are listening to the garbage that many politicians, who wish they were in Obama's position, are saying about his unreadiness for the White House. Well of course they're going to bash him if they were or are running against him. Please, do some research for yourself!!!! Stop listening to the garbage!!!!!

With either one, whether Obama or Hillary, as our presidential nominee, this nation and all its multiple peoples will experience momentous change. Among the last of several great nations to realize that women and persons of any color, are as capable as old white men to guide the destiny of a nation, we shall at last celebrate real equality. Then let us hope that all persons respectfully understand that gender and racial equality are natural rights and let us all strive to promote achievement within all cultures disseminated throughout this grand nation of ours.
Bonnie Selmer

To answer JC in LA:

Regarding providing leadership over 4 days. Traditionally at all conventions, the Nominee never shows up "on-air" before they make their acceptance speech on night 4, which is tonight. The fact that he joined Biden on Stage was done so to create even more excitement before tonight speech. Also, there is a lot that goes on behind the scenes at a convention that you never get to see anymore – how the political planks of the party platform develops (which will make up the details you're looking for) – most of which is boring and they don't show that stuff on TV anymore. Both Obama and his campaign staff have to roll up their sleeves for that part that you never see.

Everything that has taken place so far, builds up to his speech tonight. He will start getting into the details without getting into the dollars and cents – that's done in the campaign speeches after the convention.

Carl is right, the Clintons sulked after Obama got the necessary delegates. All this talk about Hilary’s supports voting for McCain is ludicrous. The next president is probably going to be able to name 3 or 4 Justices to the Supreme Court. The old McCain used to be more middle of the road and 4 years ago, he might have replaced a liberal justice with another liberal justice to keep the status quo. Since he sold his soul to the Devil 2 years ago and got the Bush Administration's support, who knows what promises he's made. If the court goes 7-2 conservative. Because the replacements are much younger, it could stay that way for the next 20-25 year and we are all in trouble. Hilary’s supporters have to know that.

Anyway, he did get what he wanted – not only did he bring the Clintons back into the party fold, they will be campaigning for him. That was totally unexpected – it did bring the party together.

I am a registered Republican and I am supporting Barack Obama and Joe Biden. I am from Pennsylvania and after years of thinking the Republicans stood for me and my core values, I have decided its just not the case. Witness the wealth issue of these candidates and proposed VPs. If you include Romney on the ticket, its about $350M net worth versus $5.15M net worth

This convention has been a new energy our country and our world desperately needs. Tired of all the hate. Tired of all the (sad but true) clinging to guns and religion. There's more to vote for than abortion and gun control.

I am sure the Democrats will welcome me.

Obama needs to define truely what change is. Without a plan on how to change things he will just be another candidate who might win an election and then fails to make due on his "promise of change".

I would like to congratulate all the "haters" on both sides of the political spectrum for making themselves look like absolute idiots who spend way to much time digging into the theasaurus.

A point was made earlier that this congress has been one of the most unproductive in the last twenty years... if the status quo of congress is maintained I doubt Obama can make much of a difference...unless of course he has a PLAN. Even if he has to change his plan later which he likely will he still needs one to start off with...otherwise its going to be another 4 years of going no where and just hoping to god that some great political, economic, and social leader steps forward. Honestly between Hillary Clinton (too much baggage), John McCain (too old), and Barrack Obama (too inexperienced and leftest) is this the best America can do?????? I suppose its pretty clear that most decent and suitable candidates who would run for and be a good choice for president simply don't want to lower themselves to the mud slinging and political backstabbing involved in modern politics.

Perhaps Biden will be another Chenny?

Perhaps Liebermann (not much younger than McCain) if selected as VP could throw a real wrench into the DNC plan?

Just a thought

Very interesting article and even more interesting comments. Bottom Line is that America needs change. We are going through such difficult times for the middle class. People are struggling to make ends meet. Decisions on whether to pay the mortgage, put food on the table or go for healthcare should not be the norm as it is today. I watch my children struggle to make it during these hard times and I pray for a change, hope for better life and try to help as best as I can. The politics of the last 8 years has not brought peace and prosperity to America. Just a steady decline. I feel that Barack Obama is the better choice for President. I know that he will make a difference, he will bring change, he will do his best for us. And that in the end is what counts.

Mary: I cannot agree with your comments more. Obama is a big show man and not a statesman. No vote for me this year.

Carl, your remarks track closely with my personal observations. I think the disappointment and dissenting views voiced by various pundits is based on their expectation of what the Republican convention will be. The fact no one was bleary eyed and looking for blood was refreshing. Having a constructive discourse with the public on matters that are important to our national interests and survival as a nation state is what Barack Obama is about. Its what his campaign has been about since day one: inclusive engaging discourse, not petty bickering and mudslinging where the only loser is the electorate, which, by the way, stands to lose everything with four more years of George Bush, operating under the guise of a John McCain presidency. I've missed some of the speeches, but my feeling of those I've seen, they are what I hope will become the future of political discourse in this country. We've had enough of the simple minded, winner-loses-all sports mentality and the gratuitous self-indulgent and sophomoric dances in the end-zone of the political arena. We need REAL CHANGE, and (although late to be an Obama convert) I've come to believe the Obama/Biden opportunity is the answer and light we've all yearned for in the angry darkness of the past 20+ years.

What specifics has McCain provided on the economy, security, healthcare, global issues, etc. Why do people keep asking for specifics ONLY from Obama? Mccain has been in the senate for over 2 decades and his voting record and his contribution needs to be scrutinised. He has never been a remarkable senator.

If I can remember correctly, George W Bush had no specific plan and won. Al Gore by contrast had the most detailed and specific plan and lost.

People don´t want specifics – People vote with their hearts 99.9% of the time. Otherwise, a young inexperienced sickly playboy senator called JFK would never have made it to the whitehouse.

Great Article. The mere fact that the Obama Campaign soundly defeated the political machine of the Clintons with a sound unwavering plan shows me that he and his team can lead this country. I was not sure of this until now. I was a New York Hillary supporter. What I think he needs to do now is put the Clintons aside and keep them quiet during the final campaign. Now, on to a great Democratic Victory in November.

Carl, withn due respect, Sen. Obama has already defined himself, time and time again, as a person. he's done that in speeches, in meetings, in writing (have you read his book?).

What kind of definition do you now want from him? or do you rather want him to re-define who he is? Do you expect him to re-invent his "me"?

Montaigne (I think) once said that "whoever attempts to define freedom ipso facto delineate it.

J-P

It is very sad that disappointed Clinton supporters are more concerned about how Hillary has been treated than the reality of what will happen under an ultra-conservative supreme court system under McCain.
Roe versus Wade and other major Supreme Court constitutional interpretations will be determined by the ideology of these new justices placed on the bench during this next administration!

Excellent article by Bernstein. But what I am most impressed by with candidate Obama is what a quick study he is. Hillary and Joe Biden were right in the primaries to say that Barack Obama had little foreign policy experience and might not be ready for the job. But what they underestimated was how quickly he could educate himself and how far he could come in a few short months, in part because of the criticism of his 'inexperience'. The contrast between the lame brain presently in the office and the intellectually tired old (albeit vital) man running for the Republicans could not be starker. Nobody starts out qualified for the office, but the potentially great ones learn (and learn quickly) what they need to know.

I am a registered Independent and I keep hearing the Republicans talking about Obama is nothing more than a empty suit, a celebrity and all the other junk that's not worth mentioning. I want to hear the Republican's plan other than continue the same ole Bush policies. The only thing I see so far that's offered from the Republicans is desperation. So far I'm seeing a empty party–all negatives and no solutions to the mess we're in.

I don't care for either of the Clintons but I thought their speeches were great. It could be because I have been watching the convention each night on the DNC Channel. No reporters, no input from anyone. Just the convention and it has been the best. I see EVERY single bit of it without commentary from news people that I may or may not agree with. I see all that is omitted by commercials etc. More people should watch it this way and I bet they would see and feel a whole different way then one does with constant input from commentators.

I haven't drank the Kool-Aid or anything, but I certainly do not want John McCain picking the next 2 -3 Supreme Court justices...that's not a risk I am willing to take, as a woman, or a supporter of civil rights.

I think those last 2 paragraphs are more important the rest of the article. In short, the Clintons underestimated Obama. It will be interesting to see if John McCain does the same. I think Obama is a more skilled politician than most people give him credit for.

All I can say that we are united as Democrats ... Obama and Hillary rivalry reminded me of sibling rivalry... with Ted Kennedy as the uncle to put things in perspective every thing fell into order ... I love our United Party... I feel so hopeful such as I did when Bill Clinton ran for office and I know that the dark days of the Republican Administration is over.... yes America... Yes we can ... we can become once again the great country of the world…

It's real sad that people that were pulling for Hillary are now going to support McCain because she's not the nominee. You weren't for changing the world into a better place, you were for Hillary. Even if we don't have a definitive answer on what Obama will do, we KNOW what McCain will do and that hasn't worked for the last 8 years! Keep throwing your fits and acting childish and if you cost Obama this election, just look in the mirror (if you still have a house to put that mirror) and blame yourself.

Obama has inspired the nation, hell, the world! I can't wait to cast my vote for the Democratic Nominee, Barack Obama!

Bill Clinton as the best orator since Reagan? No party unity before the convention? I get your point, it's just weak. Look, if you are upset Hildog lost, that's okay. But don't run your mouth. You make everyone look pathetic when you do that.

Carl,
Whether Obama or McCain wins, they will inherit the worst package of "problems" in modern times & WILL at one point wish that the other guy won. I don't envy the next president. Obama's speeches should start including statements i.e. " A great leader isn't a know-it-all, but rather surrounds himself with the best advisors in every field that needs to be addressed. Socrates said " The ONLY thing I know for certain, is that I don't know everything". John McCain stresses Obama's inexperience. Any fool can star a war. This country needs someone who is smart enough not to. If McCain gets elected we'll have the same republicans vs. democrats votes & little accomplished.
I say give the Democrats 4 years to change direction or vote them out
David, Las Vegas

TO REPEAT=
Regarding experience – would you rather have a president who graduated at the top of his Harvard Law School class in constitutional law or a president who graduated at the bottom of his class at a naval academy?

Bernstein's characterization of the Democratic Convention so far is spot on. The Clintons did very well in their efforts for party unity, and the organization of the convention does indeed reflect on how Obama will organize the government once he is elected.

The canard about Obama being arrogant is a stupid lie cooked up by self-interested opponents. He is a self-made, accomplished, determined, self-confident, and ambitious man. He has given his life in public service. Unlike the arrogant Republicans who assume God-given rights, Obama has earned his position through his own efforts, not through inherited or married wealth. Obama has devoted his talent and time to public service rather than relying on his achievements to become an arrogant Republican elitist.

Marrying a rich second wife, after leaving one who was unsuitably ill, is not a qualification to be President in spite of the newly available cash to spend on political attacks. Mr. McCain has yet to show how his experience translates to anything of public benefit. Pretending to be a maverick and then cowardly yielding to the Republican party line on taxes and torture does not earn my respect, much less my vote. How can anyone trust Mr. McCain after these flip flops?

Obama has what we need in a president. I give him my blessing now and my vote in November. Obama08!!

Let me first say that this body of work you have submitted Carl, is the most honest and professional piece of journalism I've read over the past 6 months. I wish more of your bretheren at CNN kept to the core of what journalism is about. There have been countless post on numerous blogs stating that Barack Obama isn't ready or lacks the experience to be President. To all who would read this please take note of the following: The presidency is a job that no one is trully ready to tackle from day one. Each administration has faced challenges that it's predecessor's never faced or couldn't even fathom. During the administrations of Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson, and Reagan no one had ever concieved the thought of a terrorist attack on US soil purpertrated by radical Islamist. Who knows how they would have handled it. Reagan was an excellent statesman, but had a horrible civil rights (not just rights for minorities) platform dating back to his day as Govenor of California. He too was labeled as lacking experience however, his statesmanship helped bring the Cold War to an end. LBJ was the perfect person to bring about sweeping civil rights changes based on his early carreer teaching minority children in San Antonio, and seeing firsthand the damage of segregation. Of the five presidents I listed LBJ, Eisenhower, and Kennedy are still considered great because of their acomplishments. Those same three were considered too young (Kennedy), lack of political experience (Eisenhower), and too liberal (LBJ.) None of them had previous experience in the issues that resolved, but they all had excellent vision, judgement, and the good sense to surround themselves with great peopl. Given the opportunity Barack Obama will do the same.

The only reason Hillary lost was because of Florida and Michigan. Don't you think that's a little too convenient that they wouldn't let them count?

Why would they change the dates of their primaries if they knew their votes wouldn't be counted? It was a political move to insure that Obama mama would win.

Has it occured to anyone that maybe Hillary didn't want the VP position? That she would rather focus on getting Obama elected and then plan to run again next time? Why take the VP spot when what she wanted was the top spot?
As for the comments by HC supporters STILL planning to vote for McCain, please have an open mind about what the two parties stand for. I've always believed you should vote for the person, not the party. But after seeing what the Republican administration has done to this country, I would've supported the Democrats if it had been Hillary or Obama. As Hillary said, what is most important is to support the Democratic party if we want real change. We do not want another 4 more years of status quo!
At a local and state level, party isn't as important as the person – but at the national level, when we've had to endure so much these past 8 years, I really feel that we need to have a Democratic administration in order to turn this country around. It's time for a change!