Program Note: In the next installment of CNN’s Black in America series, Soledad O’Brien examines the successes, struggles and complex issues faced by black men, women and families, 40 years after the death of the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
We devote several days on the blog to smart insight and commentary related to the special.
_____________________________________________________
Martin Luther King, III
There is an important conversation taking place across the nation regarding being Black in America. It may be characterized by three questions Blacks seem to be asking: From where have we come? Where are we now? And, where do we go from here? CNN’s “Black in America“ documentary is a fresh and compelling entry, focusing more on the second question than on the others. One very noticeable thing about the documentary is that it joins a new cast of characters, from academicians to journalists, entertainers to everyday citizens, who are not the faces and voices traditionally associated with the subject.
This crew, colorful and articulate, is empowered by 24/7 cable news and the unfettered reach of the Internet. They are a new generation of thinkers and doers, impatient with the status quo, who feel “the fierce urgency of now.” They are telling of a tectonic change in the plates that undergird our long-held understandings of being Black in America. And, they are challenged by the opportunities most ardently symbolized in the remarkable story unfolding in this year’s presidential election.
But, not so new is the “now-not yet” tension one feels observing being Black in America today. During the Civil Rights Movement of the mid-twentieth century, my father wrote eloquently of a similar anxiety in his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”. Then the tension was between African Americans’ “now”, who wanted speedy redress to segregation, and many whites’ “not yet”, particularly, among the clergy, who protested the Movement’s demands for immediate remedies as untimely.
In today’s tension, the “now” recognizes a plethora of possibilities for achieving the American Dream. It beckons those adequately prepared to claim them. But the “not yet” realizes the obstacles that render the possibilities beyond the reach of those deprived. In the mid-twentieth century, that deprivation was largely made possible legally. At the beginning of this century, the deprivation is structural.
Perhaps even more interesting is that the tension then was principally between black and white communities. Today, it is also significantly within their communities, both black and white. There is vigorous and healthy debate in each group regarding the causes and effects of high unemployment and incarceration on the one hand and low test scores and two-parent households on the other. The conversation often heats up when the subject turns to who’s responsible.
While it can be helpful to isolate the issues of being Black in America, we must be careful not to stigmatize the group. The challenges and opportunities that African Americans face are the same ones available to and confronting Americans from all walks of life, notwithstanding the disproportionate gatherings of Blacks on the high end of the challenges and the low end of opportunities, which makes their chances as a group less likely to realize the American Dream.
That brings us full circle on the current conversation regarding Blacks in America. Among the many questions, too many to cover in this writing, is whether their circumstances are solely the result of historical causes imposed by outside forces. Are other, contemporary, sources the root cause of the obstacles? What responsibility do African Americans have, individually and collectively, to remedy the problems they confront? Does the broader community have any responsibility? Stated more simply, are the good and bad things that happen to African Americans, individually and as a group, of their own making and, therefore, their sole responsibility? These are important questions that must be answered.
In that same letter to the clergy of Birmingham, my father was reminded of Reinhold Niebuhr’s observation that groups are more immoral than individuals. If that is so, are they also more irresponsible and, inversely, responsible? There seems to me to be a connection between immorality and irresponsibility/morality and responsibility. This was a point not only implied in the Birmingham letter, but also throughout my father’s sermons and writings. “We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly affects all indirectly.” The saying is true: A chain is only as strong as its weakest link. In our nation, if one link of our community is fragile, we all have a responsibility to help shore it up; if, we are going to truly be e pluribus unum, the United States of America.
Over the coming months, a gathering of organizations along with Realizing the Dream, Inc., a new nonprofit I founded, will continue this conversation in a series of summits and related activities. Our website is www.realizingthedream.org. I hope you will join us as we seek to answer these questions and work together to realize the dream.
| D-Chicago |
July 25th, 2008 5:02 pm ET Being Black in American has been paved by historical and present social and political policy. Everyone speaks of solutions while avoiding how the problems began. For instance Black females have always been forced into the position of head of the household this started during slavery when the family by law could be divided and inventory needed to be increased. When welfare was offered to African American Women during the 1960’s it required that no male be present in the home again creating the female headed household. My point is if solution are truly the goal, then true insight into how these conditions have evolved must be examined there is a beginning to every situation. Without such true insight the question will forever remain “What are the solutions?” |
|
| Dorothy L Brooks |
July 25th, 2008 5:02 pm ET I am of the baby boomer generation and I can tell you that I am disappointed and somewhat discouraged. Not by the program but this overwhelming feeling that my generation has dropped the baton and our legacy will be that we are the generation the FIRST generation that caused a regression. We benefited from being the ones who participated in sitins, work stoppages, etc but we hurt our Black family structure by not living up to our marital commitments, not marrying and staying married, not putting away the pot, crack, etc and not living the lessons learned in all those church studies that we rebelled against because we were “free”. This freedom carried a huge price tag and we are paying it. We bought into white America’s lie that we should abort our babies, love whoever we wanted, smoke what we wanted. We forgot the lessons of our forefathers that put such value and emphasis on fidelity, community, and religion. We bought into a lie and now we are reaping a whirlwind. An answer to some of this: no free ride (welfare money) unless you attend parentng classes taught by Black teachers who can empathize but lead; putting more money in education and programs for young offenders. Giving financial (tax) incentives to companies (and remove tax incentives for locating outside this country) who hire inner city workers but have those workers spend 2 or 3 hours a week in class upgrading their math and writing skills. |
|
| JC- Los Angeles |
July 25th, 2008 5:12 pm ET Very interesting talking points; I found your comment “the challenges and opportunities that African Americans face are the same ones available to and confronting Americans from all walks of life” extremely poignant. Today, people from all walks of life and all races have the ability to make the right choices, overcome obstacles, practice responsibility and display self respect; by creating a culture where nothing less is tolerated, change can begin. Unfortunately, we do not have the ability to change the past and the unjust treatment of good people; since we are not promised tomorrow, we can only do our best today which is what self respect is all about. |
|
| seah Ohio |
July 25th, 2008 5:17 pm ET Martin Luther King would be ashamed of Obama. They have Different Dreams and expectations. Rev King would not be Proud of those using Race against others, and for Seperating with the African-American Stanza. Rev King would see that as self segregation. Rev King was honorable, yet firm. Rev King Believed in the American Dream for all. Rev King wanted mutal respect for all. |
|
| Rosalind Johnson-Marshall |
July 25th, 2008 5:25 pm ET While I was certainly impressed on how the series Black in America was delivered. I have to ask what portion of other races, cultures, etc had tuned in? I believe that it would be very beneficial for all us as a people to hear from all of us on this subject of being Black in America. If we are going to have a serious discussion, about race, let’s truly discuss. While I applaud the efforts of getting national and international view points from African Americans, they are preaching to the choir, all Balck Americans know and understand the state that we are in, no matter where we fall on this vast spectrum. I would like to hear from other their beliefs, thoughts, and opinions on this subject we are not going to break barriers without serious dialogue. |
|
| Larry |
July 25th, 2008 5:30 pm ET Its amazing when you think about it. If not for the JFK airlift of Africans from Kenya to attend schools in America, of which Barack’s dad was one. Then it is somewhat unlikely that the next president of the united states of america would be bi-racial. As a Harvard graduate Obama Sr. made it possible for his american born son to get into Harvard thru the ‘legacy’ route; it was the same for Ted Kennedy, though Obama Jr was a significantly better scholar. As to Barack becoming the president of the Harvard Law Review, we cannot ignore that the qualifications for being awarded that position had been changed several years earlier; it had gone from being awarded to the student with the highest academic grade to a half-academic and half-popular vote. Blacks at Harvard had been making inroads to the Harvard Law Review long before Barack ever came along, Obama might want to give credit to those who opened doors at Harvard for him. Its a lovely day, I think I’ll go over to the park and read a book on the african american impressionist artist Allan Freelon. |
|
| Shawna Moon-Torres |
July 25th, 2008 5:36 pm ET What a great program and should be required viewing in all schools. This is a conversation that has needed to take place for many years. As a black married mother of biracial children, this is a topic that is never far from my thoughts, because one of my two children is male and even though it is difficult being black in America no matter your gender there are no words for how difficult it is to be a black male anywhere in the world. Shawna Moon-Torres |
|
| Leona - Canada |
July 25th, 2008 5:44 pm ET This series is quite an accomplishment and hats off to Soledad O’Brian and all responsible for the sensitive yet informative dialogue that has been long overdue….interesting to me due to the fact that I am a Canadian First Nations and many of the same struggles that have been shared along with the triumphs, have been felt and experienced here in Canada by many of our peoples. The reconciliation is so key to complete healing however until educating individuals all aspects of life including the poverty, lack of education, lack of parenting (& skills), lack of self-esteem, lack of self-pride and a true sense of acceptance and belonging can we begin to truly heal, understand and accept. It would be interesting to see if a follow-up would be considered by the major players and stakeholders to see how such a great educational program has reached enough individuals to stand up and make a difference as so with so many good “vehicles” of communication there never appears to be a solid follow-up and result in good acting planning. Thank you. |
|
| EJ (USA) |
July 25th, 2008 6:02 pm ET As a Harvard graduate Obama Sr. made it possible for his american born son to get into Harvard thru the ‘legacy’ route You of course forget to mention that Obama went to Columbia for undergrad. Which ‘legacy’ route allowed him to get into there? Silly comment. |
|
| Teles |
July 25th, 2008 6:21 pm ET I would like to thank you for running episode of Balck America. I am a black man, from the Republic of Rwanda but I have lived in Canada since I was a teen. Teles Minega |
|
| Roy Edwards |
July 25th, 2008 6:26 pm ET I watched your series on black in America. It portrayed the black man as not wanting to step up to the plate. It disturbed me that we are portrayed this way. Many of us want to be a part of our kids life, but many of the mothers used the kids as a wedge to control the fathers. In my own situation it got so bad that I had to just pay my support and not have anything to do with my kids. I have drove 200 miles to pick up my kids to come visit me and after I arrived she changed her mind after we had agreed. The kids didn’t understand why they couldn’t go, I later found out the she told them I didn’t want to bring them back. This is just one instance. Many Black Men go through this and after awhile just drop out of their kids life. How much can you take? Please address this issue. |
|
| Mari, Salt Lake City |
July 25th, 2008 7:16 pm ET To SEAH OHIO: So you think that Dr. King would be ashamed of Sen. Obama?????? How so? How has Sen. Obama used his race or promoted himself using his race? Your comment shows how ignorant you are! Back when Dr. King was alive and speaking against racial hatred, there were plenty of people who HATED HIM FOR EXACTLY THE SAME REASONS THEY HATE SEN. OBAMA TODAY! We ARE NOT, at least NOT YET……… a nation that looks beyond color! We STILL JUDGE people by the color of their skin. Sen. Obama has not as you, ‘Seah’ in Ohio, say ‘against others’….. no one has suggested segregation. Dr. King’s Dream IS the American Dream, where “ALL ARE CREATED EQUAL” ……… GOD WILLING WE WILL SEE THIS DREAM BECOME REALITY! |
|
| Melissa, Los Angeles |
July 25th, 2008 7:26 pm ET @ Roy Edwards it’s called the court system. You sue your ex for equal custody. Don’t blame your ex for your lack of involvement because she made it difficult - you made the choice to drop out because it became too hard. CNN didn’t “make up” the people in last night’s series. Brandon had 2 kids with 2 different women - neither which he takes care of - that’s a fact. I’m surprised no one has addressed the mother of Brandon’s baby now pregnant with twins from another man. It’s sad to see this foolishness going on. This is reality and yes I’m sure this happens with other races too. We all need to be accountable for our own actions. |
|
| Larry |
July 25th, 2008 7:39 pm ET @EJ (USA) Barack Obama, prior to his two years at Columbia, spent two years of undergrad at Occidental College, His mother was a catalyst for Barack to always strive to work hard at everything. Naturally, his mom’s & her parents contributions to his maturation get thrown under the bus. As to his entry to Columbia, have you heard of affirmative action? Mind you, I’m not saying that he wasn’t a good student, its the getting in that’s the toughest parts to schools such as Columbia & Harvard. |
|
| Mike in NYC |
July 25th, 2008 9:41 pm ET Dorothy L Brooks wrote: “We bought into white America’s lie that we should abort our babies, love whoever we wanted, smoke what we wanted.” Most of white America never shared in those “values.” White America was the principal target of the promoters of those behaviors. Shawna Moon-Torres wrote: “…there are no words for how difficult it is to be a black male anywhere in the world.” I assume you are including Mother Africa as one of those places that are “difficult” for black males. Are you saying that black men find it difficult to fit in the modern world? Perhaps this is the origin of the Angry Black Man. To Teles: You made some good points. I agree that hybrid cultures are largely dysfunctional. However, I disagree that white kids are simply embracing black music. There is definitely some adoption of black cultural norms, albeit in a rather shallow way. Whites have also become deracinated – cut off from their roots. |
|
| Laura Thompson |
July 25th, 2008 9:50 pm ET Your segment on Blacks in American was a wonderful start to open dialogue about some of the very important issues that need to be discussed in the Black communities across the country. It was very thought provoking and has really stirred up a much needed conversation on a national level. As an African American woman with an advertising and public relations firm, whose primary focus is the African American market, I would like to challenge CNN to schedule some impromptu trips several major cities across the country to continue the dialogue on local levels in forums that allow your very conscious raising segment to mobilize African Americans to continue to talk and start developing an action plan for positive change. Although it was impossible to touch on every subject of concern, it was a very good start to stimulate conversation for change. I would like to volunteer to coordinate a forum in San Antonio, Texas in hopes that you would send your team out to cover a shoot segments on CNN to start encouraging your very impactful message to continue. GREAT START CNN! |
|
| Sabrina in Los Angeles |
July 25th, 2008 11:02 pm ET My neighbor down the way is black and they moved in when I was in high school. Everyone in the neighborhood held their breath regarding their property values but they have proven to actually be very nice people. He is an accountant and very mild, quiet and educated. His girls are now grown and they are nice too. It is funny how these stereotypes make people react. Actually we should just react to the way people act not their exterior. I have met people who I would not associate with because they are criminal and ignorant….they are white by the way not another nationality. Trash is in all races/cultures/creeds and we should seek to hang out with those that are good not bad. Much like one of the guys on the special said (I am bad with names), it is a class thing more than a race thing when it comes to choosing people to socialize with…that is the right way. |
|
| Brooklyn Girl |
July 25th, 2008 11:11 pm ET For my generation Black History was not even taught in schools. The first Black History lesson I ever learned was when I watched the ROOTS series by Alex Haily on T.V. . Although I was just a child at the time, watching this changed my life. It opened my mind and made me yearn for more information about my people. In my Twenty’s I attended Medgar Ever College in Brooklyn, NY. There I took my first real course in African American History. During this course my classmate and I experienced became emotional as we learned how slavery began in this county. My point is, as Black people we have to learn and honor our past, and then we can move forward with a better perspective about what we need to do for ourselves. Thus, education is the KEY, and the quality of education must include all spectrums of our history. Black kids should learn about their history as early as possible because it will provide them with a sense of pride. I can’t speak for everyone, but I beleive that knowledge is power. |
|
| Lamont Austin |
July 25th, 2008 11:21 pm ET I had to address sean from ohio I really dont think MLK would be ashamed at all, he’s a smart man and i think he would understand that to get elected to president in america as a blackman you couldnt be a black activist, you have to be active for all people and thats what Obama is about. I dont think you all are getting the problem. The problem is that the white people that started this country subjected us to aspects they didnt even fully understand the outcome of. Aspects like punishing or killing black people if they tried to read a book, blaming black people for crimes they didnt commit (thatll make anyone disregard police a laws), one of the worst thing I’ve read about in slave times was concearning slave owners who would gather all other female slaves pregnant and non-pregnant around while one pregnant female was giving birth, at the moment the baby was born the slave owner would take the baby and slam it on the ground and crush the head of the baby with the heal of his boot, that was to insteal fear into the female slaves so that they would be to scared to escape or disobey any rule. Sounds like our forefathers were just as bad as Sadame Husane or even worse. I also think there are modern techniques that provide the same effect of fear and or intimidation. White peoples laws and ideas have created a monster and now that monster is smart in all the same ways as white people are and smarter, it can articulate better and with more power, this monster appeals to white people and black, and seemingly seems to be more fair then anyone in history regarding moving forward with improving life in the USA and this planet, that monster is named |
|
| CAROLYN JONES |
July 25th, 2008 11:27 pm ET ROY EDWARDS, I felt that black in america, was a good step on getting folks talking, but i do feel that black fathers were shown in a negative manner, since i deal with men of all colors, from all over the world. with the same exact problem as yours, dont give up on your children if you pay support,you have rights, the department of child support services, i dont what state your in but, ask the courts for a visitation order. you also may want to contact- national coalition of free men, attorney marc angelucci |
|
| august |
July 25th, 2008 11:33 pm ET I’m white in NJ and have a couple of simple questions; How many “Blacks in America” have no roots in slavery in this country and where do they fit in . Are they able to jump on the band wagon or how do we separate them for the statistics and government programs? |
|
| Louis A Chitty, III |
July 26th, 2008 1:04 am ET The Black in America Series is fairly informative (especially for whites) and is long overdue — but it is a HIGHLY watered-down version of the truth, revealing mostly only what white America is more comfortable viewing. The series steps all over itself and does not present a compelling picture of the all-encompassing nature of racism, discrimination, hatred nor of the physical, spiritual and PSYCHOLOGICAL violence that the black community has endured for generations — nor does it show a clear link between this omnipresent oppression and how it has FORCED many blacks into their current social, educational, economic, political and familial and MENTAL state. It leaves too much to individual interpretation and imagination because it tries to cover too much from too many different perspectives. Blacks can connect-the-dots with their eyes closed, but I’m not so sure whites can — or will — based on this series’ lack of passion. Showing Michael Eric Dyson (whom I truly respect) and his death-row brother was contrastive, but not especially revealing, except for some of Dr. Dyson’s comments, as was also the case of Hugly and his son. Such cases are rife in black America. These depictions might easily be saying (to white viewers): “See they came from the same family, and one made it — it was all about choice,” but being black in America is about a dearth of choices — and that is one point that the series fails to drive home. There was barely any mention of 300 years of slavery except en passant, even though this is the fundamental basis for today’s treatment of American blacks — and we hear almost nothing from whites about anything significant. We hear that blacks score lower than any group, even in undeveloped countries. The fact is that black people from ANYWHERE in the world fare better in America, (on the whole) than native-born black Americans. But this isn’t discussed, either. If CNN just wanted to get something out that is not necessarily compelling and that doesn’t offend whites, they have done a masterful job. I could have created a more compelling work and I have no particular expertise in this area. Only because it’s a lot better than nothing, I would give it a grade of C+. |
|
| Harriet Knight-Everette - Beloit, WI |
July 26th, 2008 1:10 am ET How low down are europeans willing to go… to keep control of this country…I believe in the inner most parts of my being that Obama has been duped into making “a mistake”…it is quite obvious that europeans are laying in wait for something to use against him…he will never be accepted as a viable candiate BECAUSE he is black…it’s enough to make you give up so called citizenship!!! |
|
| Dee Davis - Illinois |
July 26th, 2008 2:03 am ET On the subject “Missing Fathers”, where are the Fathers I kept waiting for someone to mention how the “System” is designed? The “System” is designed to keep the male out of the house! If a women has a child she can get help from the government if the man is NOT around. It is more beneficial to the woman - link card, subsidised housing, medical ibenefits. In order to find a solution, you must go back to the origin of the problem. The system needs to be revamped. Some incentives or assistance should be given to the FAMILY not just to single moms! |
|
| Osadolor Aiwerioghene |
July 26th, 2008 2:40 am ET I have followed your work on this very important project religiously,and i must commend your effort for a job well done.There are a couple of issues that have not been addresed in this program,which relates to segregation within the black communities in America.There is a very serious divide amongst African Americans and African immigrants who have come to regard America as home.There is so much animosity between these two groups,where African Americans tell other Black Africans to go back from the jungles they come from.This is a recurent theme at the job place,on the streets,stores and all over.This is a very serious issue that needs to be addresed.This is creating very uneasy tensions in our communities,from personal experiences.I wil very much like for this issue to be addresed,in other for us to live and grow in harmony.This will help in healing our wounds and help us share ideas in family building and most importantly,a just and humane black society in America which helps growth in values and education. |
|
| Trice |
July 26th, 2008 2:50 am ET I found the program Black in America to be quite informative. I grew up middle class in Northern California. I have family and friends of all racial backgrounds. I have been in integrated environments my entire life. Neigborhoods, school, work, church, etc. It has been a way of life. My parents provided me a wonderful life. They provided my siblings a wonderful life. I grew up with a stable, intact family, involved parents who knew what was going on with my school situtation on a daily basis. Family vacations every summer, financial resources to make sure that the only question regarding college was what college I wanted to go to. I know plenty of Black people that grew up the same way I did. I am a Black women who has a loving, beautiful, and amazing relationship with a Black man who grew up like me. I want to see more of my story. I saw a mere glimpse of it on the program. I commend the attempt to balance the success with the struggle, but there was truly a leaning towards the struggle and dispair. I feel that is what is always shown, written about, talked about, popularized in popular culture. My perpspective of the Black experience in America is largely ignored, and invisable. I have lived, and and am living a life of success, opportunity, emotional, and physical health, true diversity, and just genuine happiness. I want to see much much more of my story. |
|
| Kathleen |
July 26th, 2008 3:00 am ET Winston Churchill referred to us as the American race. That’s what we should be. Our own race made up of people from every culture, every ethnic group, every religion. |
|
| lynne |
July 26th, 2008 3:09 am ET The documentatry, Black In America was very good and educational. However, I feel that it was way too short. There should have been a discussion about what was shown and how it iwas shown, plus a little more. To me, it appeared that all of the ’successes’ were by African-Americans that were light skinned, while the “screw ups” appeared to be those of a darker hue. That wasn’t far. The income level went from poor to millionaires with their own businesses. Where were the $50,000 a year families? As a pecan brown-skin gal whose great-grandmother was dark-skinned, her grandmother light-skinned and her mother dark-skinned, I know how it feels to be treated less than (and still do) because of not looking a certain way. I have felt the sting of being treated like trash by light skinned blacks and shunned by those with means. It is not a pleasant feeling. I wish we all could look pass the racial issues that we have, but I’m not that optimistic. Because for the people that this was intended, I’ve noticed that it didn’t help them understand. But please note that Sabrina in Los Angeles is right. “Trash is in all races/cultures/creeds and we should seek to hang out with those that are good not bad.” The problem with this is that the folk that get the help most often are the ‘trash’ while the decent folk are left behind to struggle. Why? Because most often we don’t have the straight hair, light eyes and light skin. People that are HR/Personnel Directors that do the hiring in the various companies that read this, remember it is the substance that matters. Not the package. The so-called unattractive people need a job, too. |
|
| Anika Eden Chant |
July 26th, 2008 3:23 am ET Thank you for being bold enough CNN and AC360 to enlighten America on this strong fabric of the quilt in our culture as you air Black In America. I would really like to see, Black America, think “HUSBAND” and “WIFE” and renounce the terms “baby daddy” and “baby momma”. HUSBAND / WIFE means family, unity, normalcy, responsibility and wholeness. “Baby momma” and “baby daddy” means disconnect, disjointed, irresponsible, aloof, carelessness, thoughtless sex, child-bearing and not parenting. Why do SOME to Most Black American men fear being a HUSBAND but can fathom being a “baby daddy”? This fear is so much the reason why the Black American culture is in despair. Animals tend to mate without facing each other and leave litters of their reproduction to chance. I would like to see the mentality of the sexuality of Black America to rise above animal instincts to that of intelligence and forethought instead of foreplay. The pattern of family has been torn and never mended, so we adopt the terms “baby daddy/momma” to palate the dysfunction that keeps crippling the Black culture. Black America needs the complete family unit to be an even healthier contributor to society: husband, wife then children. Black in America. Nice touch. Thank you. |
|
| Lance |
July 26th, 2008 4:08 am ET As usual, you Negroes are just as confused as I suspected. You still don’t get it do you? Black people are DOOMED! You have been here for over 400 years and you haven’t even figured out that you’re not African Americans. The White Supremacists have done a marvelous job confusing each and every one of us. Got you calling your selves something that you’re not. Will we ever wake up?… Soledad, didn’t even scratch the surface of the real problems we face. She simply gave the White Supremacists an update on how well the Business of Racism (White Supremacy) is functioning. They can rest easy and continue building more Plantations (Prisons) to house all the non-white people in the known Universe. If Soledad wants to truly report on the problems with Black people let her look no further then the mirror. She’s just as confused as the people she interviewed. I’m going to leave you Negroes with some unsolicited information. All White people that are able to be a racist, is a racist suspect. That excludes babies and people that have either lost their mental faculties or never possessed adequate mental capacity to begin with. Just because White people agree with you on certain issues regarding race, does not mean they are not a racist (White Supremacist) It just means they agree with you regarding that particular issue. Please wake up! |
|
| Kerubo Ondieki Doreen |
July 26th, 2008 5:11 am ET I watched the episodes of the Black in America,every bit of it is true.Whites never abandon their culture for the blacks’ culture.so what do we expect as blacks? We blacks have to be humiliated even from our own countries by the whites simply because we want to adopt the white culture so they think they are superior to Africans..Am sorry to say this but we Africans have carried ourselves in a way to give the whites a loophole to the kind of lives we are living. There is a famous saying in swahili which states that he who abandons his culture is a slave (mwacha mila ni mtumwa)…. Africans lets respect our spouses for a good future of our kids they need a bright tomorrow!!!! |
|
| James Hansen |
July 26th, 2008 8:44 am ET STOP COMPLAINING and take responsibility for your own actions that is part of being an adult. Stop using your race as an excuse. See the other side of things if at all possible. Family values are what is the most important factor. As a white athlete I was discriminated against due to my position even though I was faster than almost everyone else and just better. A new black coach came my Senior year and I went from all-league 2nd team to the bench for a player who had never even played football before and had no clue. The scholarship offers I had just stopped but I moved on and did what I had to do. How many blacks were promoted over whites during affirmative action? Was that close to being fair? I grew up poor and without a father and turned out just fine. My mother taught me responsibility and never looked for hand outs and did not complain. We are american not african american or french american or whatever. Have most who claim to be african american even been to Africa? Black women need to stop hating on the black men. The reason they do not want to be with you is your poor controlling bossy attitude not your skin color. Racism has totally flipped around and Black’s use the race card way too much. Remember the Duke Lacrosse case? That about says it all, cry loud enough and you will be heard even though you may be wrong. That being said GO OBAMA! |
|
| Bill |
July 26th, 2008 11:23 am ET As an American man of Western African, Native American and Western European descent - I acknowledge all of my heritage - I’m glad I finally decided to leave the US, for good, 10 years ago. It’s been a breath of fresh air and a huge relief to not have deal with US style racism since my immigration to New Zealand. I can go to a high end department store here without having security follow me around like I was a thief (i.e. racial profiling). And, in every resturant, shop, store, club etc. I go to I’m mostly treated very well - if I’m not it has nothing to do with my skin colour; the person is just a jerk. I know this because I’ve had white friends complain about the same people to me. |
|
| greg daniels |
July 26th, 2008 11:32 am ET I would like to bring to your attention how the mostly white police force is turning young black boys into criminals. My son was accused of taking a white kid’s money in the bathroom at school. The white kid lied that there were witnesses, However, it tuned out that were no witnesses. My son told me that that group of white kids didn’t like him at all. The case went to court and we had a public defender. We went through three judges because they were upset that I as the father, did not let my son make any statements to the police. The public defender did not want to bring race into the picture. She felt that the case was so weak and with no evidence, that the case wouldn’t even go to trial. I’ve learned since then from talking with other people that this is done all the time to black kids in juvenile court. They wind up with scars on their records, while white kids are dealt with in juvenile court and their record is clean at the age of 18. Months later the same judge was accused by his clerk of helping the D.A. in court and telling him what questions to ask and not to ask to help convict people in court. If there ever was a lynching, I felt we were being lynched that day in court. |
|
| hali |
July 26th, 2008 12:32 pm ET O’Brien would get a “D-” on this report. Being “Black In America” is more than just the negitive side. O’Brien compiled a report for one year and all of her topics contained MORE OF THE SAME ” the struggle:” How about talking about the Positive contributions that blacks HAVE made in America. This was a LAZY report and require NO investigation or reshearch on her part. In my opinion this was one of the worse programs I have ever seen on CNN. O’Brien owes the Black community an appology or a follow up series on the CONTRIBUTIONS THAT BLACKS HAVE MADE IN AMERICA. Her report was boring, long and insulting. |
|
| Vivian |
July 26th, 2008 12:52 pm ET Greetings: I am upset that more focus was not placed on how Black Men & Women can close the economic gap and what role “Rich Black Americans” play in the process. I am also shocked that as of 2008, Black America still does not have a clue about the creation of jobs that will enable us to assist ourselves and compete in a global economy. I am an Entrepreneur who has been trying to startup a “National Computer Company” in the airline industry, I walk alone. I am in the Venture Capital/Angel Investment community seeking funding. I have dealt with Senators, Lobbying Firms, Venture Capital Firms, and Angel Investors throughout the U.S. It truly amazes me how many of us do not even know what Venture Capitalists, Angel Investors, or Lobbyists do, especially when it comes to starting companies that will enable us to compete in a global economy. What amazes me even more is the disconnect with the wealthy Black Americans and how they would rather buy big houses, diamonds, or 10 cars rather than invest in a Black Company. They treat us like the plague (my own people). You know who will hire a Black Man with a “Felony” that is trying to turn his life around, ME - The Black Entrepreneur. But first, we need to create “Black” Venture Capitalists, Angel Investors and a “Central” place that Entrepreneurs can come to receive investment from these individuals. P.S. - Thanks CNN, Soledad O’Brien, and Anderson Cooper for your hard work. Now CNN, if you could just do a story on Business Investment in the Black Community, you will really be on to something. |
|
| Regina Askia |
July 26th, 2008 1:09 pm ET As an african immigrant I am grateful for the myriad of opportunities available to one in this country. Watching the Black in America documentary I cant help but sympathize with the dark effects of a lifetime of brainwashing and ill treatment not to mention the viscious cycle of ill effects of drug abuse and alcholism in the black populace . Even in the poverty across much of Africa (children holding classrooms under trees) there is not much of the burden of being made to feel sub human. So far I have been slowly absorbed into the statistics of a divorced single mother, head of household and believe me its rough but I am getting it together as much as possible to turn things around. So I wonder how much of this black situation is personal responsibility and how much is societal impact. The power to break free or remain bound lies squarely in the choices we make each day. Oh sure the minor irritations of racism and its many intriuges abound but as most immigrants believe today I sweep your store , tommorow I manage it and in future I own it . So get off your pity pots people and get it together. |
|
| Trevor |
July 26th, 2008 1:17 pm ET As a white male in the south, I’m SICK and TIRED of being generalized. Just because I live in the south and I’m not going to vote for Obama, does that make me a racist? I’ve ALWAYS voted Republican because of their view on abortions and the economy. But this year every pollster says that we wont vote for Obama because were backwards hicks who are racist. But the news doesn’t care, because it is known race generates ratings, which all three news stations crave over actual journalism. |
|
| Aninda |
July 26th, 2008 1:47 pm ET Being “brown” ( indian, as from India) in North America and having grown up in West Africa (20+ years in Nigeria), i have always wondered at the reason why there is such a stark contrast between the meaning of Racism in North America Vs. in Africa. In my opinion the answer lies in the clear difference between “racism” (dislike towards people of color) and “racial bias” (perceiving people of color in a particular way). Although i believe that there is only a small pocket of americans who are truly “racist”, many of them are “racially biased” due to the portrayal of Blacks in the american media, music and sports industry. After all, this generation has grown up seeing rap/hip-hop videos and movies, where being black is potrayed as flashy cars, thugs and treating women as ‘Ho’s” or seeing blacks as high profile NBA and NFL atheletes. After all, how often does the media potray blacks as CEOs, Doctors, Nasa scientists etc. ? Pereception is a strong tool and this often leads to racial bias. If you make a trip to Africa, you quickly realize that this perception of ‘being black’ is so different. You dont see media showcasing young men with jeans hanging from their hips, reverese baseball caps or any bling bling. You see respectable young men, treating women with respect and driving ordinary cars, leading ordinary lives. So let us look at thr root cause of racial bias in america and let us not muddle this with racism. - “the brown guy who is probably a doctor or a 7/11 store owner” |
|
| Marilyn Miller |
July 26th, 2008 2:24 pm ET Thank you CNN for raising the issue. As I watched this morning, I had to disagree with the comment that Whites must only “think” positively about Blacks to improve the situation. First of all, many Whites do not see their racism. I read that in the blogs. Many do not understand that the first thoughts are those socialized by a racist system that promotes the stereotypes that keep people who are African American from achieving full equality in our society. As a high school teacher, I examine every day, often many times a day, the thoughts that rise in my mind when I see a student of color. I then choose to remember what I have been taught to think and realize that I can then imagine and promote a different idea. I talk to my students about racism and its insidious grip. I tell my students of color that it is not their fault that life is tougher for them. I encourage them to learn, stay in school, go to college, but on our faculty, there are only two teachers of color and the number of students of color is almost 50 %. What does that say about real opportunity and equal opportunity. |
|
| Kisanga |
July 26th, 2008 3:04 pm ET When people say “being black in America” do they mean being african-american in America? Or black human in general? Certainly the african blacks who live in America have a far different experience than what CNN is talking about. Black africans face greater discrimation from their african-american sisters and brothers than from any other race or ethnicity or group. I hope the next documentary will talk about how african-americans relate to black africans here in the US and in Africa. Mandela is not the only black african living in Africa. How about those less known? |
|
| Saadia, Bay Area |
July 26th, 2008 3:30 pm ET Congratulations to Soledad for one of the most thoughtful and articulate series on this important topic and to the AC Team for their coverage. As a boomer who grew up with the many movements that continue to inform this country today … civil rights, feminist, equal opportunity … so much of the series and many of the articles and blogs continue to resonate with me. As a NYC-born Puerto Rican, who has a white exterior and was married to a black man that produced a male child, I have grown up with racial bias and discrimination. I was amazed early on as a young girl how many in my own family were willing to accept a message of low expectations. I became labeled the rebel from within, which only served to fuel my passions and motivate me towards a different experience. I witnessed as my husband struggled with his heritage and attempted to pass for Hispanic. I witnessed his humiliation at being pulled over by a State Trooper while we were driving through New England for no other reason than he was driving a car late at night with a “white’ woman. Ironically, my husband was a NYC Highway Patrol police officer with all the required identification. That Trooper searched him and our vehicle, and detained us for 2 hours until my husband’s “status” was confirmed. Ultimately our marriage did not survive his infidelities, which resulted in other children with an absent father. I wonder if he would have been a different man had he had strong male or female role models to guide his path and help set him straight. Unfortunately, he became one of the absent father statistics Obama has recently highlighted. I have encouraged my son to embrace his inclusive heritage - Black and Puerto Rican. SInce high school he resisted those White, Black and Hispanic categories and after an open conversation with me settled on Afro-Caribbean to embrace both sides of his racial equation. Racial bias flows in all directions. In high school he asked my support to participate in the Afro Am Student Union. I attended the first meeting, as was requested, to encourage a meet-and-greet among the students and parents. I was quickly informed that we had “obviously” entered the wrong meeting room. A few jaws dropped as I thanked the observers for their concern, announced that my skin was white, my heritage was Puerto Rican, that despite my son’s light skin he was biracial, his father was black and I was present to support my son as he embraced all elements of his heritage. Not another word was said. Like DL Hughley, I too am realistic that our society has still a way to go to close the racial divide and also discussed with my son what his behavior should be if he were ever pulled over by police. My experience made it clear that any adolescent or man of color was a potential target - for cause or for no cause. This instruction proved invaluable, as he was pulled over for speeding late one night soon after being licensed and had to deal with police verbal abuse before being released. He came home shaken and it was very clear that every attempt has been made to provoke him to argue or fight with the police officer. He thanked me for teaching him how to manage such a situation and maintain his cool and composure no matter what the police officer said to him. As an educated and professional woman, I continue to reinforce the values of personal responsibility, choice, family, social justice and education in my son. He has completed a key milestone by graduating from college and holds close to the vest his responsibility to live a life that demonstrates personal integrity and strength. He does not aspire to become his father, |
|
| charley |
July 26th, 2008 4:13 pm ET way to go |
|
| Tammy |
July 26th, 2008 4:13 pm ET It’s true about black women on welfare without the black man in the home. also if you would have went a little deeper, you would have found out that most all blacks have white blood in them, because the white slave master had there way with the black women slaves. That’s why there is light complexion blacks in every famliy. So that one family was just one family out of many, many, more. |
|
| Renee |
July 26th, 2008 4:48 pm ET I found the series interesting and a good starting point in dealing with several issues. No one addressed the fact many unmarried fathers are involved in their children’s lives or single father’s raising children. And, yes mothers can place obstacles in father’s paths as they attempt to interact with their children. In relation to Brandon, he looks like someone who was out of his element and didn’t know exactly what to do, so perhaps with some guidance, he has the potential to be active in his child’s life. Finally, we should remember that the vast majority of blacks as a group are working hard everyday, raising their children and doing the best we can, like every other American. To the commentator who stated that we ’shame’ Brandon into stepping up to the plate. I would disagree with that, because Brandon needs to realize, why its important to be in his daughter’s life and the community has to step up to the plate and help him be a good parent. And, that’s from my nursing background and my legal background as an attorney who is also Black in middle America. |
|
| JoAnne Gibson |
July 26th, 2008 5:02 pm ET At 68 years old from Detrout, Michigan I saw noneof the people I knew or .know/I sawno union leadersfromthe AFL/CIO. people who made the life of the workingclass so affleuent they are now called middle class.. These were black men and women you don’t acknowledge. Shame on you. JoAnne Gibson |
|
| Lordikim |
July 26th, 2008 5:17 pm ET If America were a house then blacks would merely be renting a room. We will never be the head of household in America. Even if Barrack won the election we would still be renting rooms. He would still have to follow the laws of the land set by Whites who came before him. Blacks need to stop trying to live the American dream and focus on living the Black dream. For example: If my house burned down or I was forced from my home and I had to move into a whiteman’s house with my family there are rules that were there before my family and I got there that still needs to be abided by. There will be additional rules added because I am now there. Yet, even though I am in that whiteman’s house it is not his duty to raise my children and I don’t have to allow my children to do what he allows his to do. I have to set my rules within his rules for my children. Blacks need to establish a set of rules for blacks to live by while living under the whiteman’s roof. I care more about the solution than the problem. The solution is communication and control. We must effectively communicate with each other and take control of our family. |
|
| Faisal |
July 26th, 2008 6:14 pm ET Dr.King earned his PhD at very early age, a man who was devoted to his wife and kids,a man who persevered alot and sacrificed a lot to get education,and for social justice. Is it social justice to continue having kids out of wedlock and complain about the society, I am wondering that few want to sacrifice for their community by searching education,despising rap music and going to the length to achieve education. Any one who read the bio of Dubois and past African Americans who taught themselves to read would not be shunning education. Please stop the nonsense about we are being discriminated and fold our sleeves to work. I am a provider and the only time I see gunshot,stabbing wounds is a balck patient,shot/stabbed fed crack by onother balck. Faisal |
|
| Linda |
July 26th, 2008 6:41 pm ET When will America just be America? Not Black America not White America ,just America. For example Obama is just as much a White man as he is a Black man, but the media refer to his as a Black man . What happen to the DNA that his Mother contributed to his? Don’t get me wrong I am very proud of Obama . Why can’t he just be a very intelligent American Man? If a person Black or White , mistreat or judge a person for the color of their skin, he or she may need to check their family tree, you could be mistreating your cousin. |
|
| Steve in Albany, New York |
July 26th, 2008 9:20 pm ET MLK III should tell Barack Obama that. While he is playing good “house negro” in Europe, millions of Minority Americans are under attack by a sorry U.S. Congress, illegal aliens and their lobbyist. For example Jamiel Shaw was murder in L.A. County California by an illegal alien. CriminalSearch.com publishes the names of every Hispanic and African American citizen convicted of a crime in America. Type Pedro Espinoza’s name into their search bar he is not listed. Espinoza has not been convicted of murdering Jamiel Shaw yet, but he has been convicted and jailed prior for violating U.S. Immigration Law. Are illegal aliens in America criminals? I am just happy that the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the 2nd Amendment, because I think in the near future it is going to be used. MLK III needs to tell Obama to come clean about his VIP loan and his connection to the failing Fannie Mae. It is sad when Bill Clinton has advocated more for African Americans then Obama. I guess we are ready for a “House Negro” President, then maybe some of us in the field can get a chance. |
|
| buckti |
July 26th, 2008 9:32 pm ET I wonder if there were no television where our racial views (BLACK AND WHITE) would be today.the children could go to school without the medias influence in their minds from the night before. maybe they wouldn’t want to be a gangster, or be mad about something that happened over 100 years ago. could it be that their perceptions could change for the better.Do you think that they can see for theirselves and have a better world.What do you think ? |
|
| G. Penley |
July 26th, 2008 9:38 pm ET I am disappointed that Blacks are rushing to support Barack Obama just because he’s Black, or partly Black, anyway. This man does not represent Black America; he doesn’t even understand it. I wish a real Black American were running for President, not just a would-be who has the potential to hurt the Black cause more than help it. |
|
| Steve in Albany, New York |
July 26th, 2008 9:41 pm ET JC in Los Angeles, I disagree with your comments. Huey P. Newton, Malcom X and MLK did not die for no reason. Many would like to forget the past, and we cannot have a prosperous today without reparations and acknowledgment of the past. Jeff Fort’s connection to Muammar al-Gaddafi was real and it was a preview of the future and an alternative to Dr. Kings movement. Dr. King wanted peace and some wanted to eliminate African Americans in America. Now the militants have been created the question is when is the war going to begin. America’s going to have a discussion about the past or it is going to be a conflict worse than Palestine and Israel in North America. American Slaves got no amnesty, welfare or food stamps. They got wipes, chains, rape, segregation, and “separate but equal”. My advice is to study closely what a Jihad is and put the word American in front of it. If we do not speak the truth soon we have something far worse than the Middle East conflicts coming. |
|
| Kenyatta Johnson |
July 26th, 2008 9:58 pm ET I was very impressed @ the way each segment was displayed. As a single black female mother of two girls, I’ve always had this discussion with people on the very same topics. It’s amazing as to how some can relate and some think that I’m trying to be other than myself. |
|
| steve |
July 26th, 2008 10:08 pm ET I recently visited the Civil Rights museum in Memphis where MLK was assasinated. It was very powerful and my wife and I agreed that, for the very first time, we can appreciate just how difficult the fight was. The only thing missing is a room at the end reminding people that winning the battle isn’t enough; you have to continue to earn the rights that MLK and others fought and died for. We’ve got to address single-parenthood, teen-age pregnancies, multi-generation welfare, cime, gangs, drugs, etc. Would Dr. King be proud of what we’re doing with the rights he and others earned for us? My guess is he wouldn’t. He would probably also like to slap Jesse Jackson, up side the head. Obama 08! |
|
| tim |
July 26th, 2008 10:11 pm ET “As a Harvard graduate Obama Sr. made it possible for his american born son to get into Harvard thru the ‘legacy’ route” “You of course forget to mention that Obama went to Columbia for undergrad. Which ‘legacy’ route allowed him to get into there? Silly comment.” AA? |
|
| AP |
July 26th, 2008 10:11 pm ET I think Black In America is a positive step to educate and start breaking down barriers. Of course, many things could not be covered in such a short time, but I do agree that it starts from the commencement of our history. Black men were taken away from their families during slavery. Although this is not an excuse for a black man not to take responsibility for his family today, people do need to understand the history in order to find a solution. How do we break that unfortunate chain and help the black man to move forward? How about the employment opportunities for black people? Are they truly equal or do they still need to be ten times better than a caucasian person and still do not get the job??? These issues need to be addressed in order to move forward. I hope one day we would have a series “Black In Canada”. It is truly an “eye opener”. |
|
| Olawale Babalola |
July 26th, 2008 10:18 pm ET Having said all, we fail to realize that blacks in America actually incapacitated themselves and embrace the heinous predicament of self esteem .A lot of things contributed to this ,even though the price of freedom opens the flood gate of opportunity for them , needless to say is the the effect of education, and cultural heritage has a long way to go with it. All the aforementioned topics discussed in the blugs really shows where we are and where we are going. Nothing is as bad as the state of mind, we as black people needs to expunge off our memory , the act of slavery , the idiosyncracy that has plunged us into the deep gully of helplessnes for years. We actually ows our heritage to Africa , our fore fathers that procreated us has a culture and this is a moral guidance and must be guided jealously , embraced and we would witness a change. |
|
| Jeff Meaux, Sr. |
July 26th, 2008 10:23 pm ET We must start immediately in poor black homes and poor white homes, we must help parents help their children with language development that will help them achieve in grade school, high school and life. Many homes do not do this because the family does not exist, because there is no one that cares, or they do not know how. It is not reading skills.Reading skills is not easy to acquire without language skills, it may even be impossible. Success in school and life will be difficult, if not impossible, without adequate language development. Low self-esteem developes which often leads to poor behavior. The problem for many and for all of us becomes behavior, behavior, behavior. |
|
| Leslie |
July 26th, 2008 10:31 pm ET I have been watching this series and everything on the news because of Barack Obama runnning for president. I think that things will only change when people just see each other as people. I am voting for Barack because I agree with his policies and don’t care about his color. I don’t see people as black or white just as good or bad. However, I find myself wondering…why is it okay for blacks to have BET? Whites don’t have WET. Why are there churches who are focused only on blacks? I have been to many white churches and they never talk about color..just about God and the Bible. Why is there an African American Caucus? There is no White American Caucus. If there were these kind of things for whites, whites would be accused of being racial. If Afican Americans want to be Americans…..If Spanish Americans want to be Americans, they need to stop using their race as an excuse. They need to stop expecting to point out they are different and then expect to not be treated like they are different. There should be no BET or WET or SET…It should just be AET (American Entertainment Television)….period! My children have friends of many colors…I don’t see them as black, white, brown, yellow…just as people. They are all welcome in our home as long as they chose to behave in a polite fashion. They act like respectable people and they are therefore treated like respectable people…regardless of color. |
|
| Gerry |
July 26th, 2008 10:36 pm ET Sabrina in Los Angeles ; Black people feel the same way when whites move into their neighborhoods. I am a white person in a black neighborhood and trust me….don’t not feel guilty how you think. Out of 25 people that live in this apt complex I live in, 1 black person talks to me on a regular basis. Some of them will go out of there way to look down at the ground when they see me coming so they don’t have to make eye contact and actually speak. So, don’t feel like that feeling you have is a one way street. If you feel guilt, stop it. You would be very suprised how you might be treated if you moved into a black neighborhood. Barack Obama is going to upset a lot of black people if he gets into office. He is one person that sees the double standard and stands up for what is right, and he isn’t afraid to say it. I heard a black, liberal, talk show host trying to turn people away from Obama when he made a speach and said to many Black men are acting like boys, stand up and accept some responsibilities. Up until that speach, he supported Obama 110 % White Guilt is Over. |
|
| Ernie |
July 26th, 2008 10:50 pm ET I am tired of hearing the Black race blaming the White folks for thier problems. There are many Black people that are more educated, smarter, refined, richer,have better jobs, better homes and a lot of other things than many Whites. You can be anything that you want to be regardless of race. There are many Handicapped people that lead better lives than ones who are not. It’s up to you. I am White and Deaf. I have had a lot of Black friends. Get off your butt and make your life better. Oprah, Bill Cosby, and too many others to mention, did not get where they are by sitting on the porch and looking for excuses. Where there is a will there is a way. |
|
| Deborah Bayne |
July 26th, 2008 10:52 pm ET All I can say to Solodad O’Brien Thank You for a great documentery, please continue to keep everyone informed. |
|
| alan |
July 26th, 2008 10:55 pm ET if you black people would quit killing other blacks and quit, using crack, stop hiphop, and get jobs; maybe your people would realize the dreams. but not when you blame all others for your shortcomings. we white people are tired of 400 years of your whining. work on your dreams. |
|
| darryl |
July 26th, 2008 11:04 pm ET Idiots, affirmative action requires a percentage of minorities, meaning Women, Asians, Hispanic, Blacks, etc…. It does not require Blacks. So many of you are brought up on ignorant information and learnings, but the worst part is that you guys don’t even know it. Most university have more women on it, did they get there by affirmative action? Please. Why don’t you guys just quit complaining about gas? Then, others might stop complaining about real injustices and inequalities. BIGOTRY IS SO ALIVE. |
|
| afterdarke |
July 26th, 2008 11:20 pm ET D-Chicago is right. The only real plan that the government has had for black people is to keep us out. The fact that we have made it in is truly astounding, because it was done literally against all odds. We as black men have been subject to attempts at castration. Still we endure. If the field was level and we had equal access to opportunity our people would not suffer so badly. Like any race we have or under-achievers, however we have more stars than any other (many are not allowed to shine). The Black in America series is a series long overdue. One last thing. About the comments which stress that we get over it. Get over the past and move on. The comments that all people at some point have had it hard. The comments that we whine and cry instead of pulling ourselves up by boot straps. I would like to tell those critics, cynics, and commentators - acknowledge what the people of this country have done. Acknowledge slavery, Jim Crow, segregation, black codes, discrimination, the inability to own property, lynching, (etc)…acknowledge these. Know that we should not have to get over it or forget it. Acknowledge how our people have been hurt and oppressed. Once America truly acknowledges is criminally heinous and murderous past we can heal. WE ARE AMERICANS |
|
| T |
July 26th, 2008 11:20 pm ET Let it go, jesus christ. People are going to be the way they want. There are “certain people” who take advantage of the wrong things and dig their own holes and cast a bag image. There are too many opertunities for everyone to not make something of themselves.Look in the mirror, thats where you can find most faults. |
|
| d n kansas |
July 26th, 2008 11:24 pm ET I really get tired of listening and reading that blacks seem to have a tougher time in America. I don’t think that the color of skin has anything to do with i. I know lots of people of different color, including the color white, thay all are having a hard time surviving the economy. We have all lost jobs, homes, insurance, etc. History was a long time ago, its time to let it go and stop using it as an excuse that the world owes you. No one ever gave me anything, my husband and I worked since we were 14 and we worked until we retired at 62 years old. What we have we worked hard for. Our lives are full of disappointments, heartaches and missed loves one. So please give us a break and stop with the different color in America. We are all one America. |
|
| Matt |
July 26th, 2008 11:29 pm ET I think this election cycle really got us as a nation to reflect on were we’ve been and were we are going. It is a very useful dialog as it prompts us to reflect on ourselves, community, and state. The item I am noticing a lot in the comments of these stories is what really concerns me. It seems a select few are consistently fixated on blaming other people for their issues. Call it by whatever name you like but by speaking in such a collectivist manner it only can be called one name: Racism. Racism is not an mindset that belongs to any one group. It is an affliction that spans all people who accept the collectivist view of the world. As a nation we will never get past the race issue so long as parties from both sides are leveraging their race. We are not Afican-American, Italian-Americans, German-Americans, or any other -American. We are all just Americans and our short comings in life are the result of decisions we make. If you make bad decisions then the end result will be that of displeasure with were your life is. One can not leave proverty by not attending school, regardless of how poor the school district is doing. In closing I offer just this peice of advice: One will never excel so long as they are looking for someone to blame their failures on. By blaming a different party for your mistakes in life you are surrendering your soverign ability to fix those mistakes. |
|
| Marvin |
July 26th, 2008 11:33 pm ET As a Jew, jewish life is diverse. Jews don’t go around with a mindset that they are Jews first. Too bad African Americans can’t get their mental arms around the concept. If they could they wouldn’t be preoccupied with being African American. As a jew, The Constitution is first in my life, because all other apsects of who I am are as a result of our revolutionary Constitution. Think about it; You are who you are because of the social environment provided by the Constitution of this fabulous country. The next time you hear the ranting of patriotism look closely to see if the expressor of patriotism pays homage to the document which makes their ranting possible. If they do, then they are patriots. And remember, “OLD GLORY” is the symbol of our Constitution. |
|
| constance |
July 26th, 2008 11:44 pm ET in reference to hip hop and its influence on black life…black people arent ignorant. where do you think the rappers get their ideas? art imitates life. not everyones life naturally but enough lives for the music to have a following. dont like hip hop then change the way we live and treat one another. |
|
| Angela in Seattle but from Alaska |
July 27th, 2008 12:05 am ET I watched. I learned. Angela |
|
| Bill, Columbus, Ohio |
July 27th, 2008 12:06 am ET “We bought into white America’s lie that we should abort our babies, love whoever we wanted, smoke what we wanted…” As another blogger has noted, this is NOT a lie from “white America” and to say so merely perpetuates one of the fundamental problems in black culture, namely a lack of accountability. No one is making ANYONE do anything. You choose to have sex, to have an abortion, to keep the baby, to smoke the pipe, whatever…those are choices YOU are making. You can always make better choices. When one isn’t willing to assume personal accountability, it’s so much easier to blame somebody else for all the bad stuff that happens. In most cases, the root cause is staring right at you from your mirror. When you see someone blaming someone else for the bad things that have happened to them, you pass on by. When they blame themselves and ask you for help in not letting it happen again, you help them…and we help each other. The cycle of “it’s not my fault” has to stop….now. |
|
| Ludlow |
July 27th, 2008 12:11 am ET @Roy Edwards: I totally empathize with you. There are many men who desperately want to honor their responsibilities as fathers but are prevented from doing so by the mothers of the children and a grossly disfunctional court/social system. I have a WONDERFUL relatiopnship with my 14 y/o daughter but it took me 4 attorneys and the threat of jail time from the judge before she saw it fit to honor my visitation rights. Fortunately I had the resources and the deep moral conviction to force her to respect my rights as a father. Melissa, Los Angeles, your response is a bit short sighted . A lot of men do not have the resources or grow tired from being worn out by a social/court system weighted against men. This is an issue that needs urgent attention because our children are suffering |
|
| Denise Groves |
July 27th, 2008 12:13 am ET I have been trying to watch the program every since the first night. I find it fascinating and intriguing. Other times, it is downright depressing! On the whole, we are a strong people! to be here after all we have endured is incredible. |
|
| K Killingsworth |
July 27th, 2008 12:56 am ET While I appreciate the comments from MLK III, I must underscore the fact that resposibility for crime in the United States is the resposibility of the person or persons committing the crimes. Personal responsibility is the key to advancement of a culture. If a group seeks to blame society for the ills of the groups, that group will never achieve equality. Society must never tolerate excuses being made for crime and criminals regardless of race. |
|
| MICHAEL FROM N.CAROLINA |
July 27th, 2008 1:05 am ET As black people who now enjoy the rights won during the 50’s and ’60s, we have an urgent need to face the complex problems related to the wholesome values that somehow have become diluted within so many of our families and neighborhoods. Our youth get blamed for a great deal of this, but they can only know that which they have been taught. There is tremendous denial and a tendency to focus only on the bigotry of white people as a major obstacle. As Bill Cosby indicated, we as parents must make sure our kids can read. Blaming the schools is a cop-out. The appreciation for literacy is a seed that must be sown and nurtured at home. Otherwise, our youth will only know as much as someone tells them. We must recognize complexity but also keep that which is simple, simple. |
|
| Rosie |
July 27th, 2008 1:32 am ET While Black’s are on display, let me add this comment. America has no racial problem. What America is doing is living up to an evil report put together by one man, as giving his opinion of the African American’s. And from this one man’s opinion, six statesmen, in 1864, entered this one man’s opinion into congress, and from this one man’s opinion, the behavior toward the African-American’s, by the white world was shaped. |
|
| B. Westphal |
July 27th, 2008 2:11 am ET What a great piece of research. The Moynihan Report:1960’s Black Familes in Crisis was on point. Athough ,hiv was not in our community back then. |
|
| Pete, San Francisco |
July 27th, 2008 2:19 am ET One of the toughest aspects of getting an education or maintaining a marriage is teen pregnancy. Furthermore, there are numerous teens and single welfare mothers who continue to have additional children out of wedlock (of all races and colors). I think there can be a case made to incentivize birth control to reduce the occurrence of teen pregnancy and pregnancy of welfare mothers, of any color. The milions of dollars spent on prenatal care, the pregnancy, and extended welfare could be used to financially incent people to use birth control and as well as fund our school system. With fewer teen pregnancies, there is a greater likelihood that a person will complete high school and go to college. This is also true for the male counterparts. Less stress and less responsibility from not having children at an early age would allow them to finish school and wait to have children until later in life. This proposal does not promote teen sex. It simply tries to get to the heart of the problem in today’s America. |
|
| Stephen Berg |
July 27th, 2008 2:24 am ET Seah Ohio: I see Mr. Obama as the best hope for uniting this country. He seems to me to have a profound understanding and respect for all people. And I believe Dr. King not only would be proud but would champion a man whom he has provided shoulders upon which to stand. On the issue of being Black in America, enormous gains have been made. But there is a long way to go. When Black anger is harnessed and focused on fighting for equal educational opportunity and not on deifying convention and playing into white racist stereotypes more gains will be made. The more people can identify with others, the less they fear. As Whites confront their overt ,and even more importantly, their covert racism we all stand a better chance of moving forward. Education is crucial as is political leadership. Mr. Obama has my vote in this regard. He absolutely gets it. |
|
| Brendan Steuble |
July 27th, 2008 2:37 am ET Dear Mr King- I am glad your father did not choose Terrorism. I have listened to our society complain about the treatment of blacks and jews by others my entire life. I never treated anyone badly. I find it poor timing to be complaining about the black man, period. That is over: I was not a slave owner, nor was the president. There may be some rich guys left who’s money descends from slavery: go get em. Leave me alone. I do not care for your travails any more than you care for mine. My best wishes for yourself and your family, Brendan Steuble |
|
| Susan |
July 27th, 2008 3:17 am ET How did Geogre Bush get into Yale? We all know how. |
|
| Arleen B. Anderson |
July 27th, 2008 3:18 am ET I am very dissapointed in Soladad Obrien. First of all what was her purpose for doing this series. She didn’t accomplish anything nor did she provide any information that we didn’t already know. Blacks are quite aware of were we are in America. We didn’t need some wanna be journalist to tell us that. She should be ashamed of herself. Why doesn’t she investigate her own people, i.e. the hispanics and talk about how decadent their lifestyle is. I could have appreciated it better if she would have at least stated her purpose, presented the information, and offered some solutions or gave a “call to action.” But, I’m sure that wasn’t a part of her personal agenda for this program. She didn’t do any research, all she did was take someone else’s information and presented it This research was done years ago. This was not a year long investigation; she out right lied. Why would present a program that decpicted a race of people in such an awful way and not offer solutions. If she’s so smart why didn’t offer a solution. I’m sure at some point in her investigation (that she did not do) that she spoke with someone that offered some sort of solutions. Solodad has become a part of the problem. She used black people to advance her own journalistic agenda and I hope she reaps what she has sown. If CNN gives her an award for that mess she presented blacks should boycott the network. I hope she reads this comment personally so she will how I feel about her. Respectfully submitted. |
|
| Steve M |
July 27th, 2008 3:30 am ET I found especially important the comment that read “while it can be helpful to isolate the issues . . . we must be careful not to stigmatize the group.” In the ‘deep south,’ such as my home, South Carolina, this is a crucial thing to keep in mind I believe. I think it might be that something of a tension between the generation that came of age in the Civil Rights era, and the generation coming of age today. Today whites and blacks more often don’t mind spending more time on the “other side of the train tracks,” as it would go in the city I grew up in. In Senator Obama’s book he referred to a huge “cross-polinization” taking place across the country today, traditional barriers separating groups being broken. I’m of the younger generation, a first time voter in my 25th year. I say that today’s challenge is to help the underpriveledged -white and black- understand that the problems they face are the same. That it’s not another race they should fear and loathe; it is, generally speaking, the corporation; the powerful and opulent groups that manipulate our lives in so many fashions. Both the black and white family struggle for such basic necessities as health care, an obvious problem that quite frankly I don’t think will change soon. But I have hope, and it’s not just in a politician. |
|
| Jason Williams |
July 27th, 2008 3:40 am ET I hope none of you get offended if we ever have a Whites In America broadcast. Oh that’s right. The double standard. I forgot. |
|
| Sandy |
July 27th, 2008 3:48 am ET Soledad, I commend you for making the incision and bursting the boil. |
|
| Brandon Smithson |
July 27th, 2008 4:46 am ET I am a white male that came from a single parent household with no money. I served several years in the military to earn money for college. I studied hard and graduated with a 4.0 GPA (All A’s). While attending a community college, I visited the financial aid office in hopes of finding academic scholarships. To my dismay, there were none. There were a corkboard full of scholarship applications, and they were for either minorities or single mothers. I felt like the victim of racism. This is not something I heard about happening to someone else of what happened in my ancestry. This is racism that happened to me personally. I was denied a scholarship because of the color of my skin. |
|
| Robert Jr. James McClendon |
July 27th, 2008 5:30 am ET I’m just glad that someone perhaps had the complexion for the connection to say something about being Black in America. Many of us needed that little reminder. The journalist who did the program just came off the bench on the subject, but somebody had to step in. If you feel it could have been done better, do it yourselves with “activism”. Thanks CNN! |
|
| Sean |
July 27th, 2008 6:25 am ET Here’s what I don’t get… We have Black Americans stating they should be taught by Black teachers, go to Black doctors, live in predominantly Black neighborhoods, etc. Here’s an idea: How about we drop this segregation idea and actually integrate our communities. How best to come together and learn from each other than to actually live and work side by side? Black Americans are justifiably fighting for equal rights on all fronts, yet they spend more time fighting to stay apart from society as a whole. Even more, how about we place a level of responsibility on the individual. Why do we blame “society” for the problems? Children going to unsafe schools are the fault of the dangerous children and their parents, not society. Good parenting leads to good children, which leads to safer schools. Safer schools leads to smarter students, which leads to more opportunities for these children. Yes, there are always going to be bad seeds regardless of good parenting, but that is a small percentage. Enough blaming everyone else. Be accountable for your actions, strive to be more, work hard, get an education, have respect for yourself AND others, and let go of unnecessary hatred. Stop blaming the people of today for the sins of the past. |
|
| Elaine Aniton |
July 27th, 2008 10:31 am ET Very one-sided documentary…If I had a daughter engaged in an interracial relationship…I would be concerned. This type of reporting re-enforces all myths and stereotypes. Social problems, i.e., HIV, crime and lack of parental responsibility is not the majority, rather the minority. Most black households are split; half believes society owes them something, half are contributing members. Cycles need to be broken and it starts with the family. Balanced reporting can be very instrumental in bringing about change. |
|
| Monica Ajayi |
July 27th, 2008 5:32 pm ET Hats off to Soledad for her exceptional work on Being Black in America. Soledad, I hope you are awarded “Journalist of the Year” for your work. You are passionate about this issue and you proved that you are on top of your game. Being Black in America left me wondering where do we go from here? My husband is from Nigeria and I am an educated African American woman that was fortunate enough to grow up with both parents and I have always lived a comfortable middle class life. I am deeply saddened by the inequality that exists in education as well as by the lack of options for black men without a college degree. This documentary has inspired me to work with my husband who is a very successful IT professional and inner city schools to introduce technology as fun and hip. When people are strong technologist, skin color becomes less of a factor. Soledad, we will let you know how we do in this area. Hopefully we will be successful and we can spear head a program that will take off nationally. Your journalism efforts will certainly assist with the success. My husband and I owe it to young black people to step up and do something. God blessed us and it is time to work for God!!! Thank you for the inspiration Soledad!! Monica Ajayi in Southern NJ |
|
| malkeeya |
July 27th, 2008 6:59 pm ET I think it is important for Soledad O’Brien to balance this conversation by looking at Being White in America, role of class, history, ethnicity etc there. Being Native American in America, Being Latino in America, Being Asian in America. If the goal is to increase understanding amongst us, then we must look at everyone instead of just singling out Black America. |
|
| jeff |
July 27th, 2008 7:00 pm ET When is CNN going to do a special on Chinese in America or the US have a Chinese American History month? Is there a white history month or any other Race specific history month other than BLACK.Grow up people, forget this foopaw that you deserve more, you only make it harder on yourself for reliving the past. Yes I am white! |
|
| Irma Robinson |
July 27th, 2008 7:01 pm ET Mr. Marshell, please continue to ask for dialog as this is very important. It will give a chance for me to say things as I just said and be challenged, i hope. I was amased to see another Value placed on my culture because it is believed falsely that the African-American culture must leave off the African part. When in fact that in Africa our culture began with the hunter-gathers which has and still have the Mother as the head of the house hold with full rights to Vote!!!! The older the female the more respected and admired and looked up to.Some thing unheard of in the American | |


